RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 10 JAN S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Mathematics question — Differentiability at a point

Let f:(−1,1)→Rf: (-1, 1) \to R be a function defined by f(x)=max⁡{−∣x∣,−1−x2}f(x) = \max\left\{-|x|, -\sqrt{1-x^2}\right\}. If KK be the set of all points at which ff is not differentiable, then KK has exactly:

SOLUTION

We are given the function f:(−1,1)→Rf:(-1,1)\to\mathbb R defined by

f(x)=max⁡{− ∣x∣,  − 1−x2 }f(x)=\max\left\{-\,|x|,\;-\sqrt{\,1-x^{2}\,}\right\}

On the interval (−1,1)(-1,1) the two candidate functions inside the maximum are

g1(x)=− ∣x∣andg2(x)=− 1−x2 .g_{1}(x)=-\,|x| \quad\text{and}\quad g_{2}(x)=-\sqrt{\,1-x^{2}\,}.

To decide which of the two is actually equal to f(x)f(x) at a particular point, we compare their values. For this we first find the points where the two are equal:

We set g1(x)=g2(x)g_{1}(x)=g_{2}(x), so

− ∣x∣=− 1−x2   .-\,|x|=-\sqrt{\,1-x^{2}\,}\;.

Multiplying both sides by −1-1 (which does not affect equality) gives

∣x∣= 1−x2 .|x|=\sqrt{\,1-x^{2}\,}.

Both sides are non-negative, so we can square them safely:

∣x∣2=( 1−x2 )2  ⟹  x2=1−x2.|x|^{2}=\left(\sqrt{\,1-x^{2}\,}\right)^{2}\;\Longrightarrow\;x^{2}=1-x^{2}.

Adding x2x^{2} to both sides yields

2x2=1  ⟹  x2=12  ⟹  x=±12.2x^{2}=1\;\Longrightarrow\;x^{2}=\frac12\;\Longrightarrow\;x=\pm\frac1{\sqrt2}.

Thus the two graphs meet only at x=12x=\dfrac1{\sqrt2} and x=−12.x=-\dfrac1{\sqrt2}. Next we check which of the two functions is larger (because the larger one is selected by the max operator) on either side of these points.

Take x=0x=0. We have g1(0)=0g_{1}(0)=0 and g2(0)=−1.g_{2}(0)=-1. Clearly g1(0)>g2(0),g_{1}(0)>g_{2}(0), so near the origin the function ff equals g1(x)=− ∣x∣.g_{1}(x)=-\,|x|.

Take x=0.9x=0.9 (any value with ∣x∣|x| close to 1). Then

g1(0.9)=−0.9,g2(0.9)=−1−0.92=−0.19≈−0.435.g_{1}(0.9)=-0.9,\qquad g_{2}(0.9)=-\sqrt{1-0.9^{2}}=-\sqrt{0.19}\approx-0.435.

Now g2(0.9)>g1(0.9),g_{2}(0.9)>g_{1}(0.9), so near the ends of the interval (−1,1)(-1,1) the function ff equals g2(x)=−1−x2.g_{2}(x)=-\sqrt{1-x^{2}}. Therefore the piece-wise description of ff is

f(x)={− ∣x∣,∣x∣≤12,− 1−x2 ,∣x∣≥12.f(x)= \begin{cases} -\,|x|, & |x|\le\dfrac1{\sqrt2},\\[6pt] -\sqrt{\,1-x^{2}\,}, & |x|\ge\dfrac1{\sqrt2}. \end{cases}

We now locate the points where ff fails to be differentiable. There are two possible sources:

(i) points where the selected branch itself is not differentiable;

(ii) junction points where the branch changes (i.e. where ∣x∣=12|x|=\dfrac1{\sqrt2}).

First consider g1(x)=− ∣x∣.g_{1}(x)=-\,|x|. The absolute-value function ∣x∣|x| is not differentiable at x=0,x=0, therefore g1(x)g_{1}(x) is not differentiable at x=0x=0. Since ∣0∣=02≤12,|0|=\dfrac0{\sqrt2}\le\dfrac1{\sqrt2}, the branch g1g_{1} is indeed active at x=0x=0, so

x=0x=0 is a point where ff is not differentiable.

Everywhere else g1g_{1} has a constant one-sided derivative: for x>0,  g1′(x)=−1;x>0,\;g_{1}'(x)=-1; for x<0,  g1′(x)=+1.x<0,\;g_{1}'(x)=+1. So no other singularity comes from g1g_{1} itself.

Next consider g2(x)=− 1−x2 .g_{2}(x)=-\sqrt{\,1-x^{2}\,}. Inside (−1,1)(-1,1) the function  1−x2 \sqrt{\,1-x^{2}\,} is differentiable, so its negative is also differentiable; hence g2g_{2} has no internal cusps.

Thus the remaining possible trouble points are where the branch changes, namely x=12x=\dfrac1{\sqrt2} and x=−12.x=-\dfrac1{\sqrt2}. We inspect the derivatives on either side of each such point.

Formula for the derivative of g2g_{2}: First write g2(x)=− 1−x2 .g_{2}(x)=-\sqrt{\,1-x^{2}\,}. Using the chain rule,

ddx[− 1−x2 ]=−12 1−x2 ⋅(−2x)=x 1−x2 .\frac{d}{dx}\bigl[-\sqrt{\,1-x^{2}\,}\bigr] =-\frac1{2\sqrt{\,1-x^{2}\,}}\cdot(-2x) =\frac{x}{\sqrt{\,1-x^{2}\,}}.

Now compute the derivatives at the junctions.

1. Point x=12>0x=\dfrac1{\sqrt2}>0 Left of this point the active branch is g1(x)=−∣x∣g_{1}(x)=-|x| with derivative −1.-1. Right of this point the active branch is g2(x)g_{2}(x) with derivative

g2′ ⁣(12)=121−12=1212=1.g_{2}'\!\left(\frac1{\sqrt2}\right) =\frac{\frac1{\sqrt2}}{\sqrt{1-\frac12}} =\frac{\frac1{\sqrt2}}{\frac1{\sqrt2}} =1.

The left-hand derivative is −1-1 and the right-hand derivative is +1,+1, so they are unequal. Hence

x=12x=\dfrac1{\sqrt2} is a point where ff is not differentiable.

2. Point x=−12<0x=-\dfrac1{\sqrt2}<0 Left of this point (more negative) the active branch is g2g_{2} with derivative

g2′ ⁣(−12)=−121−12=−1212=−1.g_{2}'\!\left(-\frac1{\sqrt2}\right) =\frac{-\frac1{\sqrt2}}{\sqrt{1-\frac12}} =\frac{-\frac1{\sqrt2}}{\frac1{\sqrt2}} =-1.

Right of this point the active branch is g1(x)=−∣x∣g_{1}(x)=-|x| which, for negative x,x, has derivative +1.+1. Again the two one-sided derivatives, −1-1 and +1,+1, are different, so

x=−12x=-\dfrac1{\sqrt2} is also a point where ff is not differentiable.

Combining all our findings, the set KK of points of non-differentiability is

K={−12,  0,  12},K=\left\{-\dfrac1{\sqrt2},\;0,\;\dfrac1{\sqrt2}\right\},

which clearly contains exactly three elements.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Differentiability at a point. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicDifferentiability at a point
TypeMultiple choice