Let . Let be the set of points in the interval at which is not differentiable. Then :
We begin with the definition of the function
We have to find all points in the open interval where is not differentiable. Whenever a piece-wise definition changes its analytic form, or whenever the chosen expression itself is non-smooth, a lack of differentiability can occur. Therefore we examine
1. the internal switch between and when ,
2. the boundary points where the first case is replaced by .
First we focus on the part , where
To understand which of the two quantities and is larger, we solve the equality
For we have , so
giving or . For we have , hence
yielding or . Thus the two expressions intersect at
Now test which term dominates in each sub-interval:
• If , observe that , so there.
• If , the inequality reverses to , hence there.
• Exactly at and at the two alternatives are equal, i.e. or respectively.
Because itself contains a corner at , we inspect the derivative around that point. For small positive we have
while for small negative we get
The two one-sided limits differ, so is not differentiable at .
Next consider the points where the maximum operator switches from to . We compute the derivatives of each candidate expression:
For ,
Approaching from the left (values slightly less than 1) we are in the region , so the left-hand derivative equals . Approaching from the right we use , so the right-hand derivative equals . Because , is not differentiable at .
By symmetry the same reasoning applies at . For we have , whereas at . The values and are unequal, hence is not differentiable at .
We have thus far obtained the points inside the interval .
Now we turn to the boundary , i.e. and , where the analytic form of switches from the “maximum” description to the linear expression .
Inside and close to we are in the sub-region , so there. Its derivative is
which at equals . Outside that boundary, for , we have (because is positive). The derivative of is . Since , the derivatives do not match, hence is not differentiable at .
For the inside expression is still , whose derivative equals at that point. For we write , so
whose derivative is . Again , so is not differentiable at .
Collecting all points found, the set where fails to be differentiable inside is
Looking at the given alternatives, this coincides with Option A.
Hence, the correct answer is Option A.
Tagged Differentiability at a point. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.