RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 03 SEP S1+4MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Mathematics question — Cube roots and nth roots of unity

If (1+i1−i)m2=(1+ii−1)n3=1\left(\frac{1+i}{1-i}\right)^{\frac{m}{2}} = \left(\frac{1+i}{i-1}\right)^{\frac{n}{3}} = 1, (m,n∈N)(m, n \in N) then the greatest common divisor of the least values of m and n is

SOLUTION

We begin by rewriting each complex fraction in polar (exponential) form so that taking powers becomes straightforward.

The numerator 1+i1+i has modulus 2\sqrt{2} and argument π4\dfrac{\pi}{4}, so we write it as 2 e iπ/4.\sqrt{2}\,e^{\,i\pi/4}. The denominator 1−i1-i also has modulus 2\sqrt{2} but argument −π4-\dfrac{\pi}{4}, so it is 2 e −iπ/4.\sqrt{2}\,e^{\,-i\pi/4}.

Hence

1+i1−i=2 e iπ/42 e −iπ/4=e iπ/4+iπ/4=e iπ/2=i.\frac{1+i}{1-i}= \frac{\sqrt{2}\,e^{\,i\pi/4}}{\sqrt{2}\,e^{\,-i\pi/4}}=e^{\,i\pi/4+i\pi/4}=e^{\,i\pi/2}=i.

In the second fraction the denominator is i−1=−(1−i).i-1 = -(1-i). Multiplying by −1-1 multiplies the modulus by 11 (unchanged) but adds π\pi to the argument. Therefore

1+ii−1=−1+i1−i=− e iπ/2=e −iπ/2=−i.\frac{1+i}{i-1}= -\frac{1+i}{1-i}= -\,e^{\,i\pi/2}=e^{\,-i\pi/2}= -i.

Now the equation of the question can be rewritten as

(i) m/2=1and(−i) n/3=1,\left(i\right)^{\,m/2}=1\qquad\text{and}\qquad\left(-i\right)^{\,n/3}=1,

with m,n∈N.m,n\in\mathbb N. We handle the two conditions separately.

First condition. Using the identity eiθ=1⟺θ=2πk, k∈Z,e^{i\theta}=1\Longleftrightarrow\theta=2\pi k,\ k\in\mathbb Z, we write

i=e iπ/2,soi m/2=e i(π/2) m/2=e iπm/4.i=e^{\,i\pi/2},\qquad\text{so}\qquad i^{\,m/2}=e^{\,i(\pi/2)\,m/2}=e^{\,i\pi m/4}.

Setting this equal to 1 gives

e iπm/4=1⟹πm4=2πk⟹m=8k.e^{\,i\pi m/4}=1\Longrightarrow \frac{\pi m}{4}=2\pi k\Longrightarrow m=8k.

The least positive natural value is obtained when k=1,k=1, so mmin⁡=8.m_{\min}=8.

Second condition. The number −i-i has modulus 11 and, because the argument of a complex number is defined up to addition of multiples of 2π2\pi, we may choose any of its valid arguments: −i=e i(−π/2+2πk),k∈Z.-i=e^{\,i\left(-\pi/2+2\pi k\right)},\quad k\in\mathbb Z.

Raising to the power n/3n/3 we get

(−i) n/3=e i(−π/2+2πk)n/3=1.(-i)^{\,n/3}=e^{\,i\left(-\pi/2+2\pi k\right)n/3}=1.

Again using eiθ=1⟺θ=2πr, r∈Z,e^{i\theta}=1\Longleftrightarrow\theta=2\pi r,\ r\in\mathbb Z, we equate arguments:

(−π2+2πk)n3=2πr.\left(-\frac{\pi}{2}+2\pi k\right)\frac{n}{3}=2\pi r.

Dividing by π\pi and simplifying,

(−12+2k)n3=2r⟹n (4k−1)=12r.\left(-\frac{1}{2}+2k\right)\frac{n}{3}=2r\Longrightarrow n\,(4k-1)=12r.

To find the least positive nn we can choose integers k,rk,r to make nn as small as possible.

  • If k=0k=0, the factor 4k−1=−14k-1=-1, giving n=12(−r),n=12(-r), whose least positive value is 12.12.
  • If k=1k=1, the factor 4k−1=34k-1=3, giving 3n=12r⟹n=4r.3n=12r\Longrightarrow n=4r. Taking r=1r=1 yields n=4,n=4, which is smaller than 12.
  • If k≥2,k\ge 2, the factor 4k−1≥7,4k-1\ge 7, which makes nn even larger.

Thus the least positive value satisfying the second condition is nmin⁡=4.n_{\min}=4.

Finally we need the greatest common divisor of these least values:

gcd⁡(mmin⁡,nmin⁡)=gcd⁡(8,4)=4.\gcd(m_{\min},n_{\min})=\gcd(8,4)=4.

So, the answer is 4.4.

Tagged Cube roots and nth roots of unity. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicCube roots and nth roots of unity
TypeNumerical answer