RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2012TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2012 Mathematics question — Modulus and conjugate

Let Z1Z_1 and Z2Z_2 be any two complex number. Statement 1: ∣Z1−Z2∣≥∣Z1∣−∣Z2∣|Z_1 - Z_2| \geq |Z_1| - |Z_2| Statement 2: ∣Z1+Z2∣≤∣Z1∣+∣Z2∣|Z_1 + Z_2| \leq |Z_1| + |Z_2|

SOLUTION

The two inequalities used in the question are standard results for vectors (hence also for complex numbers regarded as vectors in the Argand plane).

Statement 2: ∣Z1+Z2∣≤∣Z1∣+∣Z2∣|Z_1+Z_2|\le |Z_1|+|Z_2|

This is the ordinary triangle inequality.
Geometrically, the length of one side of a triangle (the vector Z1+Z2Z_1+Z_2) cannot exceed the sum of the lengths of the other two sides (the vectors Z1Z_1 and Z2Z_2).
Algebraically, representing Z1Z_1 and Z2Z_2 by their coordinates and squaring both sides confirms the result.
Therefore Statement 2 is always true.

Statement 1: ∣Z1−Z2∣≥∣Z1∣−∣Z2∣|Z_1-Z_2|\ge |Z_1|-|Z_2|

This is the reverse triangle inequality.
Start from the triangle inequality applied to Z1Z_1 and −Z2-Z_2:

∣Z1−Z2∣≤∣Z1∣+∣−Z2∣=∣Z1∣+∣Z2∣|Z_1- Z_2|\le |Z_1|+|-Z_2|=|Z_1|+|Z_2| −(1)-(1)

Interchange Z1Z_1 and Z2Z_2 in −(1)-(1) to get

∣Z2−Z1∣≤∣Z2∣+∣Z1∣|Z_2- Z_1|\le |Z_2|+|Z_1|

But ∣Z2−Z1∣=∣Z1−Z2∣|Z_2-Z_1|=|Z_1-Z_2|, so −(1)-(1) is symmetric and provides no new information.
To obtain the reverse form, write the triangle inequality for Z1Z_1 and Z2Z_2 in the alternative way:

∣Z1∣=∣(Z1−Z2)+Z2∣≤∣Z1−Z2∣+∣Z2∣|Z_1| = |(Z_1-Z_2)+Z_2|\le |Z_1-Z_2|+|Z_2|

Re-arranging gives ∣Z1∣−∣Z2∣≤∣Z1−Z2∣|Z_1|-|Z_2|\le |Z_1-Z_2|.
If ∣Z1∣<∣Z2∣|Z_1| \lt |Z_2|, then ∣Z1∣−∣Z2∣|Z_1|-|Z_2| is negative while ∣Z1−Z2∣≥0|Z_1-Z_2|\ge 0, so the inequality is still satisfied.
Thus Statement 1 is also always true.

Are the statements logically connected as explanation ↔ result?
Statement 2 states the ordinary triangle inequality, whereas Statement 1 states the reverse triangle inequality. Although both arise from the geometry of a triangle, Statement 2 does not logically imply Statement 1, nor is Statement 1 derived by a direct application of Statement 2 alone. They are therefore independent truths rather than an explanation-conclusion pair.

Hence the correct choice is:
Option B which is: Statement 1 is true, Statement 2 is true, Statement 2 is not a correct explanation of Statement 1.

Tagged Modulus and conjugate. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicModulus and conjugate
TypeMultiple choice