JEE Main 2019 Mathematics question — Family of circles
Three circles of radii a, b, c (a<b<c) touch each other externally. If they have x-axis as a common tangent, then:
SOLUTION
First we note that each of the three circles is tangent to the x-axis from above. Hence the centre of the circle whose radius is a can be written as O1(x1,a), the centre of the circle whose radius is b as O2(x2,b) and that of the circle whose radius is c as O3(x3,c).
Because all three circles touch one another externally, the distance between any two centres equals the sum of the corresponding radii. Using the distance formula (distance)2=(difference of abscissae)2+(difference of ordinates)2, we can write three separate equations.
For the pair O1O2 we have
(x1−x2)2+(a−b)2=(a+b)2.
For O1O3 we have
(x1−x3)2+(a−c)2=(a+c)2.
For O2O3 we have
(x2−x3)2+(b−c)2=(b+c)2.
From the first equation we obtain
(x1−x2)2=(a+b)2−(b−a)2=4ab,
so
∣x1−x2∣=2ab.
The second equation gives
(x1−x3)2=(a+c)2−(c−a)2=4ac,
so
∣x1−x3∣=2ac.
The third gives
(x2−x3)2=(b+c)2−(c−b)2=4bc,
so
∣x2−x3∣=2bc.
Because a<b<c, the smallest circle is most naturally sandwiched between the other two on the common tangent. We therefore assume the left-to-right order
x2<x1<x3,
so that
x1−x2=2ab,x3−x1=2ac,x3−x2=2bc.
Now we use the simple relation of collinear points on a line:
x3−x2=(x3−x1)+(x1−x2).
Substituting the expressions just found, we get
2bc=2ac+2ab.
Dividing every term by 2abc simplifies the equation:
abcbc=abcac+abcab.
Simplifying each fraction separately, we find
a1=b1+c1.
This is exactly the relation stated in Option A, while none of the other options follow from the geometry. Hence, the correct answer is Option A.
Tagged Family of circles. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.