RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 07 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Mathematics question — Rolle's theorem and Lagrange's mean value theorem

Let the function f:[−7,0]→Rf : [-7, 0] \rightarrow R be continuous on [−7,0][-7, 0] and differentiable on (−7,0)(-7, 0). If f(−7)=−3f(-7) = -3 and f′(x)≤2f'(x) \le 2 for all x∈(−7,0)x \in (-7, 0), then for all such functions ff, f(−1)+f(0)f(-1) + f(0) lies in the interval

SOLUTION

We have a function f:[−7,0]→Rf:[-7,0]\to\mathbb R which is continuous on the closed interval [−7,0][-7,0] and differentiable on the open interval (−7,0)(-7,0). The values already known are f(−7)=−3f(-7)=-3 and, for every x∈(−7,0)x\in(-7,0), the derivative satisfies f′(x)≤2f'(x)\le 2.

To relate the values of the function at different points we use the Mean Value Theorem (MVT). The MVT states that for any two points a,ba,b in the interval with a<ba<b, there exists a point c∈(a,b)c\in(a,b) such that

f(b)−f(a)=f′(c) (b−a).f(b)-f(a)=f'(c)\,(b-a).

Because f′(c)≤2f'(c)\le 2, the difference f(b)−f(a)f(b)-f(a) cannot exceed 2(b−a)2(b-a). Expressed as an inequality,

f(b)≤f(a)+2 (b−a).f(b)\le f(a)+2\,(b-a).

We now apply this inequality twice, once for the pair (−7,−1)(-7,-1) and once for the pair (−7,0)(-7,0).

First take a=−7,  b=−1a=-7,\;b=-1. Then b−a=(−1)−(−7)=6b-a=(-1)-(-7)=6, so

f(−1)≤f(−7)+2⋅6=−3+12=9.f(-1)\le f(-7)+2\cdot 6 =-3+12 =9. Thus

f(−1)≤9.f(-1)\le 9.

Next take a=−7,  b=0a=-7,\;b=0. Now b−a=0−(−7)=7b-a=0-(-7)=7, hence

f(0)≤f(−7)+2⋅7=−3+14=11.f(0)\le f(-7)+2\cdot 7 =-3+14 =11. So

f(0)≤11.f(0)\le 11.

Adding the two individual inequalities gives an upper bound for the required sum:

f(−1)+f(0)≤9+11=20.f(-1)+f(0)\le 9+11=20. Hence, whatever the admissible function,

f(−1)+f(0)≤20.f(-1)+f(0)\le 20.

We must also decide whether there is a finite lower bound. Observe that the derivative condition f′(x)≤2f'(x)\le 2 places no restriction on how negative the derivative may be; it can be any negative number. Therefore the function is free to decrease as steeply as we like.

To see this concretely, fix a very large positive number NN and construct a simple piecewise-linear example:

For x∈[−7,−1]x\in[-7,-1] set f(x)=−3−N (x+7).f(x)=-3-N\,(x+7). Here the constant slope is f′(x)=−Nf'(x)=-N, which respects the inequality f′(x)≤2f'(x)\le 2 because −N<2-N<2 for every positive NN.

At x=−1x=-1 the value is

f(−1)=−3−N (6)=−3−6N.f(-1)=-3-N\,(6)=-3-6N.

On the short interval [−1,0][-1,0], let the function rise with the maximum permitted slope 22: f(x)=f(−1)+2 (x+1),x∈[−1,0].f(x)=f(-1)+2\,(x+1),\qquad x\in[-1,0]. This keeps the derivative equal to 22 and ensures differentiability at x=−1x=-1.

Then at x=0x=0 we obtain

f(0)=f(−1)+2 (0+1)=(−3−6N)+2=−1−6N.f(0)=f(-1)+2\,(0+1) =(-3-6N)+2 =-1-6N.

The sum of the two required values is therefore

f(−1)+f(0)=(−3−6N)+(−1−6N)=−4−12N.f(-1)+f(0)=(-3-6N)+(-1-6N)=-4-12N.

As N→∞N\to\infty the number −4−12N-4-12N tends to −∞-\infty. So by choosing a sufficiently large NN, the sum f(−1)+f(0)f(-1)+f(0) can be made arbitrarily negative. Consequently, there is no finite lower bound; the set of all possible values extends indefinitely towards −∞-\infty.

Combining the results, we have established that

−∞<f(−1)+f(0)≤20.-\infty<f(-1)+f(0)\le 20.

Thus the entire range of admissible sums is the interval (−∞, 20](-\infty,\,20].

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Rolle's theorem and Lagrange's mean value theorem. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicRolle's theorem and Lagrange's mean value theorem
TypeMultiple choice