We are given the curve y=x3+3x2+5 and the tangent at (x1,y1) passes through the origin.
Find the tangent equation.
The slope at (x1,y1) is y′=3x12+6x1.
The tangent line: y−y1=(3x12+6x1)(x−x1).
Apply the condition that the tangent passes through the origin.
Substituting (0,0): −y1=(3x12+6x1)(−x1)
y1=3x13+6x12
Use the fact that (x1,y1) lies on the curve.
y1=x13+3x12+5
Equating: x13+3x12+5=3x13+6x12
2x13+3x12−5=0
Solve the cubic.
Testing x1=1: 2+3−5=0 ✓
Factoring: (x1−1)(2x12+5x1+5)=0
The discriminant of 2x12+5x1+5 is 25−40=−15<0, so the only real solution is x1=1.
y1=1+3+5=9. So (x1,y1)=(1,9).
Check which curve (1, 9) does NOT lie on.
Option A: 1+8181=1+1=2 ✓
Option B: 981−1=9−1=8 ✓
Option C: 4(1)+5=9 ✓
Option D: 31−81=−3242=2 ✗
Answer: Option D