RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2014 · 11 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2014 Mathematics question — Local maxima and minima and concavity

The volume of the largest possible right circular cylinder that can be inscribed in a sphere of radius = 3\sqrt{3} is:

SOLUTION

Let the given sphere have radius R=3  .R=\sqrt{3}\;. We wish to fit inside it a right circular cylinder having base-radius rr and height hh in such a way that the volume is as large as possible.

The axis of the “right” cylinder will pass through the centre of the sphere, so if we measure upward from the centre, the top rim of the cylinder has coordinates (r, y)\bigl(r,\,y\bigr) in a suitable coordinate system. This point must lie on the sphere, therefore we have the relation of the sphere:

r 2+y 2=R 2  .r^{\,2}+y^{\,2}=R^{\,2}\;.

The total height of the cylinder is twice the half-height yy, that is

h=2y  .h = 2y\;.

Now we write the formula for the volume of a right circular cylinder:

Volume V=π (base-radius)2×(height)  .V=\pi \,(\text{base-radius})^{2}\times(\text{height})\;.

So, substituting the symbols we are using,

V=πr 2 h=πr 2 (2y)=2πr 2y  .V = \pi r^{\,2}\,h = \pi r^{\,2}\,(2y)=2\pi r^{\,2}y\;.

Because yy is related to rr through the sphere equation, we solve that equation for yy:

y 2=R 2−r 2    ⟹    y=R 2−r 2  .y^{\,2}=R^{\,2}-r^{\,2}\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; y=\sqrt{R^{\,2}-r^{\,2}}\;.

Now we can express the cylinder’s volume as a function of only one independent variable, namely rr:

V(r)=2πr 2R 2−r 2  .V(r)=2\pi r^{\,2}\sqrt{R^{\,2}-r^{\,2}}\;.

To obtain the maximum volume we differentiate with respect to rr and set the derivative equal to zero.

First we compute the derivative. Write V(r)=2π f(r)V(r)=2\pi\,f(r) with f(r)=r 2(R 2−r 2)1/2  .f(r)=r^{\,2}(R^{\,2}-r^{\,2})^{1/2}\;. Using the product rule and the chain rule:

ddrf(r)=2r(R 2−r 2)1/2+r 2⋅12(R 2−r 2)−1/2⋅(−2r)  .\dfrac{d}{dr}f(r)=2r\bigl(R^{\,2}-r^{\,2}\bigr)^{1/2}+r^{\,2}\cdot\dfrac{1}{2}\bigl(R^{\,2}-r^{\,2}\bigr)^{-1/2}\cdot(-2r)\;.

Simplifying inside the brackets:

ddrf(r)=2r(R 2−r 2)1/2−r 3(R 2−r 2)1/2  .\dfrac{d}{dr}f(r)=2r(R^{\,2}-r^{\,2})^{1/2}-\dfrac{r^{\,3}}{(R^{\,2}-r^{\,2})^{1/2}}\;.

Therefore

dVdr=2π[ 2r(R 2−r 2)1/2−r 3(R 2−r 2)1/2 ]  .\dfrac{dV}{dr}=2\pi\left[\,2r(R^{\,2}-r^{\,2})^{1/2}-\dfrac{r^{\,3}}{(R^{\,2}-r^{\,2})^{1/2}}\,\right]\;.

For a maximum or minimum we set this derivative equal to zero. The factor 2π2\pi and the denominator (R 2−r 2)1/2(R^{\,2}-r^{\,2})^{1/2} are never zero within the sphere, so we concentrate on the numerator:

2r(R 2−r 2)−r 3=0  .2r(R^{\,2}-r^{\,2})-r^{\,3}=0\;.

Now we solve step by step:

2r(R 2−r 2)−r 3=02r(R^{\,2}-r^{\,2})-r^{\,3}=0

⟹  2rR 2−2r 3−r 3=0\Longrightarrow\; 2rR^{\,2}-2r^{\,3}-r^{\,3}=0

⟹  2rR 2−3r 3=0\Longrightarrow\;2rR^{\,2}-3r^{\,3}=0

⟹  r(2R 2−3r 2)=0  .\Longrightarrow\; r\bigl(2R^{\,2}-3r^{\,2}\bigr)=0\;.

The factor r=0r=0 would correspond to no cylinder at all, so we take the other factor equal to zero:

2R 2−3r 2=02R^{\,2}-3r^{\,2}=0

⟹  r 2=23R 2\Longrightarrow\; r^{\,2}=\dfrac{2}{3}R^{\,2}

⟹  r=R23  .\Longrightarrow\; r=R\sqrt{\dfrac{2}{3}}\;.

Next we find yy and then hh. From y=R 2−r 2y=\sqrt{R^{\,2}-r^{\,2}} we have

y=R 2−23R 2=13R 2=R3  .y=\sqrt{R^{\,2}-\dfrac{2}{3}R^{\,2}}=\sqrt{\dfrac{1}{3}R^{\,2}}=\dfrac{R}{\sqrt{3}}\;.

So the optimal cylinder’s height is

h=2y=2⋅R3=2R3  .h = 2y = 2\cdot\dfrac{R}{\sqrt{3}}=\dfrac{2R}{\sqrt{3}}\;.

Now substitute these optimal dimensions back into the volume formula:

Vmax=πr 2h=π(23R 2)(2R3)=π⋅23⋅23 R 3=4πR 333  .V_{\text{max}}=\pi r^{\,2}h =\pi\left(\dfrac{2}{3}R^{\,2}\right)\left(\dfrac{2R}{\sqrt{3}}\right) =\pi\cdot\dfrac{2}{3}\cdot\dfrac{2}{\sqrt{3}}\,R^{\,3} =\dfrac{4\pi R^{\,3}}{3\sqrt{3}}\;.

Finally we put the numerical value R=3R=\sqrt{3} into this expression.

Because R 3=(3)3=33  ,R^{\,3}=(\sqrt{3})^{3}=3\sqrt{3}\;, we get

Vmax=4π (33)33=4π  .V_{\text{max}}=\dfrac{4\pi\,(3\sqrt{3})}{3\sqrt{3}}=4\pi\;.

Thus the largest possible right circular cylinder that can be inscribed in the given sphere has volume 4π  .4\pi\;.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Local maxima and minima and concavity. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicLocal maxima and minima and concavity
TypeMultiple choice