RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2023 · 01 FEB S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2023 Chemistry question — Adsorption and adsorption isotherms

Given below are two statements:
Assertion A: Amongst He, Ne, Ar and Kr; 1 g of activated charcoal adsorbs more of Kr.
Reason R: The critical volume Vc_c (cm3^3 mol−1^{-1}) and critical pressure Pc_c (atm) is highest for Krypton but the compressibility factor at critical point Zc_c is lowest for Krypton.

SOLUTION

Activated charcoal adsorbs a gas more strongly when the attractive van der Waals forces between its molecules are larger. For the noble gases those forces grow with increasing ease of liquefaction, or equivalently with higher critical temperature TcT_c. The critical temperatures are:

He : 5.2 K < Ne : 44.4 K < Ar : 150.9 K < Kr : 209.4 K.

Since krypton has the highest TcT_c, 1 g of activated charcoal will adsorb the greatest quantity of Kr. Hence Assertion A is true.

The Reason states that krypton has the highest critical volume VcV_c and critical pressure PcP_c, but the lowest compressibility factor at the critical point ZcZ_c. Experimental critical constants are:

He : Pc=2.3 atm,  Vc=57 cm3 mol−1,  Tc=5.2 KP_c=2.3\ \text{atm},\;V_c=57\ \text{cm}^3\ \text{mol}^{-1},\;T_c=5.2\ \text{K}
Ne : Pc=26.3 atm,  Vc=41 cm3 mol−1,  Tc=44.4 KP_c=26.3\ \text{atm},\;V_c=41\ \text{cm}^3\ \text{mol}^{-1},\;T_c=44.4\ \text{K}
Ar : Pc=48.3 atm,  Vc=74.6 cm3 mol−1,  Tc=150.9 KP_c=48.3\ \text{atm},\;V_c=74.6\ \text{cm}^3\ \text{mol}^{-1},\;T_c=150.9\ \text{K}
Kr : Pc=55.0 atm,  Vc=92.0 cm3 mol−1,  Tc=209.4 KP_c=55.0\ \text{atm},\;V_c=92.0\ \text{cm}^3\ \text{mol}^{-1},\;T_c=209.4\ \text{K}

Thus Kr indeed has the highest PcP_c and VcV_c among the four gases. However, the compressibility factor at the critical point is

Zc=PcVcRTcZ_c=\frac{P_cV_c}{RT_c}

Using the data above gives Zc Z_c\,: He 0.302, Ne 0.296, Ar 0.291, Kr 0.294. Krypton does not possess the lowest ZcZ_c; argon’s value is slightly lower. Therefore the statement “ZcZ_c is lowest for krypton” is false, rendering Reason R false.

A true Assertion with a false Reason matches Option A.

Final answer : Option A.

Tagged Adsorption and adsorption isotherms. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicAdsorption and adsorption isotherms
TypeMultiple choice