We recall the van der Waals relation between the critical temperature Tc and the constants a and b:
Tc=27Rb8a
Here R is the universal gas constant. Since R is the same for all gases being compared, the factor 27R8 is common and need not be calculated explicitly. Thus, for the purpose of comparison, the critical temperature is directly proportional to the ratio ba.
So, to find which gas has the highest Tc, we need to compute ba for each gas. The given data are:
Argon (Ar): a=1.3atm dm6 mol−2,b=3.2×10−2dm3 mol−1
Neon (Ne): a=0.2atm dm6 mol−2,b=1.7×10−2dm3 mol−1
Krypton (Kr): a=5.1atm dm6 mol−2,b=1.0×10−2dm3 mol−1
Xenon (Xe): a=4.1atm dm6 mol−2,b=5.0×10−2dm3 mol−1
Now we evaluate the ratios one by one.
For Ar: ba=3.2×10−21.3=0.0321.3=40.625
For Ne: ba=1.7×10−20.2=0.0170.2=11.7647
For Kr: ba=1.0×10−25.1=0.015.1=510
For Xe: ba=5.0×10−24.1=0.054.1=82
We observe that:
ba(Ne)<ba(Ar)<ba(Xe)<ba(Kr)
Since Tc∝ba, the gas with the largest ba value will possess the highest critical temperature. The highest ratio is clearly for Krypton (Kr) with a value of 510.
Hence, the correct answer is Option A.