RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2017 · 08 APR ONLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2017 Chemistry question — Real gases, compressibility factor and van der Waals equation

Among the following, the incorrect statement is:

SOLUTION

We recall that a gas behaves ideally when the van der Waals corrections for intermolecular attraction and molecular volume become negligible. Mathematically, the van der Waals equation is first written

(P+aVm 2) ⁣(Vm−b)=RT,\left(P + \dfrac{a}{V_m^{\,2}}\right)\!\left(V_m - b\right) = RT,

where PP is pressure, VmV_m is molar volume, TT is absolute temperature, RR is the gas constant, and the constants aa and bb account for attraction and finite molecular size, respectively. A gas will approach ideal behaviour when the two correction terms aVm 2\dfrac{a}{V_m^{\,2}} and bb are very small compared with the other quantities present in the equation.

We now examine each experimental condition in the four options one by one, always asking whether those two corrections really become negligible.

Option A: “at low pressure, real gases show ideal behaviour.”

At low pressure we have P→0P \rightarrow 0. From the ideal gas relation PVm=RTPV_m = RT we see that Vm→∞V_m \rightarrow \infty when PP becomes very small (with TT fixed). Because VmV_m is now very large, the attraction term

aVm 2→0\dfrac{a}{V_m^{\,2}} \rightarrow 0

and the molecular volume correction bb is also negligible compared with the huge VmV_m. Hence the van der Waals equation reduces to PVm=RTPV_m = RT, which is the ideal gas law. So Option A is a correct statement.

Option B: “at very low temperature, real gases show ideal behaviour.”

At very low temperature we have T→0T \rightarrow 0 (in practice, simply “much lower than room temperature”). Substituting a small TT into the ideal gas law PVm=RTPV_m = RT requires either a very small pressure or a very small volume if the product PVmPV_m is to stay equal to RTRT. In reality, however, molecules at low temperature possess little kinetic energy, so the attractive forces between them (represented by aa in the van der Waals equation) become more significant. Consequently the correction term aVm 2\dfrac{a}{V_m^{\,2}} cannot be neglected; it in fact dominates the behaviour, often leading to liquefaction. Therefore real gases deviate strongly from ideality at very low temperatures. Option B is therefore an incorrect statement.

Option C: “at Boyle's temperature, real gases show ideal behaviour.”

Boyle’s temperature TBT_B is defined as the temperature at which the second virial coefficient B(T)B(T) becomes zero, i.e.

B(TB)=0.B(T_B) = 0.

The virial expansion PVmRT=1+B(T)Vm+…\dfrac{PV_m}{RT} = 1 + \dfrac{B(T)}{V_m} + \dots then gives PVmRT=1\dfrac{PV_m}{RT} = 1 when T=TBT = T_B, even for a moderate range of pressures. Hence real gases do behave ideally at Boyle’s temperature. Option C is a correct statement.

Option D: “at very large volume, real gases show ideal behaviour.”

Very large molar volume is the same physical situation as very low pressure: molecules are far apart. As already shown for Option A, large VmV_m makes aVm 2→0\dfrac{a}{V_m^{\,2}} \rightarrow 0 and makes bb negligible. So the gas again obeys PVm=RTPV_m = RT, i.e. ideal behaviour. Option D is therefore a correct statement.

We find that Options A, C, and D are correct statements, whereas Option B is not. Therefore the one and only incorrect statement is Option B.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Real gases, compressibility factor and van der Waals equation. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicReal gases, compressibility factor and van der Waals equation
TypeMultiple choice