RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 10 APR S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Real gases, compressibility factor and van der Waals equation

Consider the following table:

Gas    a/(kPa dm6^6 mol−1^{-1})    b/(dm3^3 mol−1^{-1})
A              642.32                    0.05196
B              155.21                    0.04136
C              431.91                    0.05196
D              155.21                    0.4382

a and b are van der Waals constants. The correct statement about the gases is:

SOLUTION

We begin by writing the van der Waals equation. For n moles of a real gas the equation is stated as

(P+an2V2) (V−nb)=nRT.\left(P+\frac{a n^{2}}{V^{2}}\right)\,(V-nb)=nRT.

Here aa corrects the pressure term for intermolecular attractions, while bb corrects the volume term for the finite size of the molecules. A larger aa therefore signifies stronger attractions (the gas can be squeezed more easily), and a larger bb signifies a larger “excluded volume’’ per mole (each mole physically occupies more space).

To compare the four gases we put n=1n=1 (one mole):

(P+aV2) (V−b)=RT.−(1)\left(P+\frac{a}{V^{2}}\right)\,(V-b)=RT. \quad -(1)

Throughout the comparison we imagine all gases kept at the same temperature TT and pressure PP so that the right-hand side, RT,RT, is the same for every gas.

Comparison of gases A and C (volume occupied)

For gas A aA=642.32  kPa dm6 mol−1,bA=0.05196  dm3 mol−1.a_A = 642.32\;\text{kPa dm}^6\text{ mol}^{-1},\qquad b_A = 0.05196\;\text{dm}^3\text{ mol}^{-1}.

For gas C aC=431.91  kPa dm6 mol−1,bC=0.05196  dm3 mol−1.a_C = 431.91\;\text{kPa dm}^6\text{ mol}^{-1},\qquad b_C = 0.05196\;\text{dm}^3\text{ mol}^{-1}.

Both gases have exactly the same value of b,b, but gas A possesses a larger value of aa than gas C. From equation (1) we see that for a fixed PP the factor (P+aV2)\displaystyle\left(P+\frac{a}{V^{2}}\right) becomes larger when aa is larger. To keep the product equal to the constant RT,RT, the other factor (V−b)(V-b) must then become smaller. Therefore,

aA>aC⟹(VA−b)<(VC−b)⟹VA<VC.a_A > a_C\quad\Longrightarrow\quad (V_A-b) < (V_C-b)\quad\Longrightarrow\quad V_A < V_C.

Thus one mole of gas C occupies more volume than one mole of gas A under identical conditions.

Comparison of gases B and D (ease of compressibility)

For gas B aB=155.21,  bB=0.04136.a_B = 155.21,\; b_B = 0.04136.

For gas D aD=155.21,  bD=0.4382.a_D = 155.21,\; b_D = 0.4382.

Both gases have the same value of a,a, so the attraction effect is identical. Their difference lies in bb: gas D has a much larger excluded volume than gas B. To see how this affects compressibility, we rewrite equation (1) in the form of the compressibility factor ZZ:

Z  =  PVRT  =  VV−b  −  aRTV.−(2)Z \;=\; \frac{PV}{RT}\;=\;\frac{V}{V-b} \;-\; \frac{a}{RTV}. \quad -(2)

The first term VV−b\dfrac{V}{V-b} (the repulsive correction) becomes larger as bb becomes larger, making ZZ increase above 1. A larger ZZ indicates that the gas resists compression (its volume is already “puffed up’’ by repulsions). Consequently, a gas with the larger bb is less compressible.

Because bD≫bB,b_D \gg b_B, we have

ZD>ZB⟹gas D is less compressible than gas B.Z_D > Z_B \quad\Longrightarrow\quad \text{gas D is less compressible than gas B}.

Equivalently, gas B is more compressible than gas D.

Putting both parts together

We have shown that

(i) Gas C occupies more volume than gas A, and

(ii) Gas B is more compressible than gas D.

The option that states both facts correctly is Option C.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Real gases, compressibility factor and van der Waals equation. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicReal gases, compressibility factor and van der Waals equation
TypeMultiple choice