RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 09 JAN S1+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Solubility of gases and Henry's law

Which one of the following statements regarding Henry's law is not correct?

SOLUTION
image

We begin by recalling Henry's law, which establishes a relation between the pressure of a gas above a liquid solution and the mole fraction of that gas dissolved in the liquid. The law is stated mathematically as

P=KH xP = K_H \, x

where

PP is the partial pressure of the gas in the vapour phase above the solution,

xx is the mole fraction of the gas dissolved in the liquid, and

KHK_H is Henry’s law constant, characteristic of the particular gas-solvent pair at a given temperature.

From the relation P=KH xP = K_H \, x we can algebraically solve for the mole fraction xx to see how it depends on KHK_H:

Dividing both sides by KHK_H, we obtain

x=PKHx = \dfrac{P}{K_H}

This expression x=PKHx = \dfrac{P}{K_H} shows explicitly that, when the pressure PP is kept the same, the mole fraction xx (which directly represents the solubility of the gas in the liquid) is inversely proportional to the constant KHK_H. In simpler words, for a fixed external pressure,

• If KHK_H is large, the denominator in PKH\dfrac{P}{K_H} is large, so the mole fraction xx becomes small, meaning the gas is less soluble.

• If KHK_H is small, the denominator is small, so xx becomes large, meaning the gas is more soluble.

Therefore, a higher value of KHK_H corresponds to lower solubility of the gas in the liquid.

Now let us analyse each statement in the question one by one using the facts above.

Statement A: “Different gases have different KHK_H values at the same temperature.”
This is true, because KHK_H depends on the nature of the gas as well as the solvent.

Statement B: “The partial pressure of the gas in the vapour phase is proportional to the mole fraction of the gas in the solution.”
This is exactly the verbal form of Henry’s law P=KHxP = K_H x, so it is correct.

Statement C: “Higher the value of KHK_H at a given pressure, higher is the solubility of the gas in the liquids.”
Using x=PKHx = \dfrac{P}{K_H}, we found that a higher KHK_H actually lowers the solubility. Hence this statement is incorrect.

Statement D: “The value of KHK_H increases with increase of temperature and KHK_H is function of the nature of the gas.”
Empirically, for most gases, KHK_H indeed rises with temperature because gases become less soluble as temperature increases; it is also well known that KHK_H varies with the identity of the gas. Thus this statement is correct.

Only Statement C contradicts the true relationship derived from Henry’s law, so it is the one that is not correct.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Solubility of gases and Henry's law. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
ChapterSolutions
TopicSolubility of gases and Henry's law
TypeMultiple choice