For 1 molal aqueous solution of the following compounds, which one will show the highest freezing point?
First, recall the colligative‐property relation for depression of the freezing point
where is the lowering of the freezing point, is the cryoscopic constant of water, is the molality, and is the van’t Hoff factor (the total number of solute particles produced per formula unit on complete dissociation).
In this problem every solution is 1 molal, and the solvent (water) is the same. Hence and are identical for all the options. The only variable is . A larger gives a larger , which means a bigger lowering of the freezing point and therefore a smaller final freezing temperature. Conversely, the compound with the smallest will have the least depression and thus the highest freezing point.
We must therefore calculate for each compound by writing its dissociation in water. Inside the square brackets of a coordination complex the ions are bound covalently and stay together; only species outside the brackets (counter-ions and waters of crystallisation) can separate in solution.
Option A [Co(HO)Cl].3HO
The entire unit inside brackets is electrically neutral, and there are no counter-ions. Waters of crystallisation merely mix with the solvent and do not create additional solute particles. Therefore
Number of particles = 1, so .
Option B [Co(HO)]Cl
The complex has charge +3; three Cl ions are outside the bracket. Dissociation:
Particles = 1 + 3 = 4, so .
Option C [Co(HO)Cl]Cl.HO
The complex has charge +2; two Cl ions are outside. Dissociation:
Particles = 1 + 2 = 3, so .
Option D [Co(HO)Cl]Cl.2HO
The complex has charge +1; one Cl ion is outside. Dissociation:
Particles = 1 + 1 = 2, so .
Now we compare:
Since is the smallest, the freezing-point depression is the least for Option A, giving it the highest actual freezing point among the four solutions.
Hence, the correct answer is Option A.
Tagged Depression in freezing point. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.