RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 11 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Abnormal molar mass and van't Hoff factor

The freezing point of a diluted milk sample is found to be −0.2°C-0.2°C, while it should have been −0.5°C-0.5°C for pure milk. How much water has been added to pure milk to make the diluted sample?

SOLUTION

We begin with the well-known relation for freezing-point depression,

ΔTf=iKfm,\Delta T_f = iK_f m,

where ΔTf\Delta T_f is the lowering in freezing point, ii is the van’t Hoff factor, KfK_f is the cryoscopic constant, and mm is the molality of the solute present. For a given solvent (water in this case) and a fixed solute (the dissolved milk solids), the factors ii and KfK_f remain the same. Hence, for two samples prepared from the same original milk, the ratio of their freezing-point lowerings equals the ratio of the concentrations of milk solids in the two samples.

Pure milk shows a freezing point of

Tpure=0 ∘ ⁣C−0.5 ∘ ⁣C=−0.5 ∘ ⁣C,T_{\text{pure}} = 0 \,^ \circ\! \text{C} - 0.5 \,^ \circ\! \text{C} = -0.5 \,^ \circ\! \text{C},

so its depression is

ΔTf,pure=0.5 ∘ ⁣C.\Delta T_{f,\text{pure}} = 0.5 \,^\circ\! \text{C}.

The diluted sample freezes at

Tdiluted=0 ∘ ⁣C−0.2 ∘ ⁣C=−0.2 ∘ ⁣C,T_{\text{diluted}} = 0 \,^\circ\! \text{C} - 0.2 \,^\circ\! \text{C} = -0.2 \,^\circ\! \text{C},

so its depression is

ΔTf,diluted=0.2 ∘ ⁣C.\Delta T_{f,\text{diluted}} = 0.2 \,^\circ\! \text{C}.

Using the proportionality of depression to concentration, we write

ΔTf,dilutedΔTf,pure  =  mdilutedmpure  =  CdilutedCpure,\frac{\Delta T_{f,\text{diluted}}}{\Delta T_{f,\text{pure}}} \;=\; \frac{m_{\text{diluted}}}{m_{\text{pure}}} \;=\; \frac{C_{\text{diluted}}}{C_{\text{pure}}},

where CC denotes the concentration of milk solids (proportional to the volume of pure milk present per unit total volume).

Substituting the numerical values,

0.20.5=CdilutedCpure⟹CdilutedCpure=0.4.\frac{0.2}{0.5} = \frac{C_{\text{diluted}}}{C_{\text{pure}}} \quad\Longrightarrow\quad \frac{C_{\text{diluted}}}{C_{\text{pure}}} = 0.4.

Thus the diluted milk contains only 40 % of the concentration of milk solids that pure milk does.

Let us suppose we started with xx cups of pure milk and then added yy cups of water. The amount of milk solids remains proportional to xx, while the total volume becomes x+yx + y. Therefore, the concentration of milk solids in the mixture is

Cdiluted=xx+y.C_{\text{diluted}} = \frac{x}{x + y}.

Because the concentration of pure milk itself is, by definition, 1 (or 100 %), we have

xx+y=0.4.\frac{x}{x + y} = 0.4.

Now we solve this equation step by step:

x=0.4(x+y)x = 0.4(x + y)

x=0.4x+0.4yx = 0.4x + 0.4y

x−0.4x=0.4yx - 0.4x = 0.4y

0.6x=0.4y0.6x = 0.4y

y=0.60.4xy = \frac{0.6}{0.4}x

y=1.5x.y = 1.5x.

This tells us that the volume of water added is 1.5 times the volume of the original milk. Converting 1.5 : 1 into whole-number cups, we multiply by 2 to avoid fractions:

Water:Milk  =  1.5:1  =  32:1  =  3:2.\text{Water} : \text{Milk} \;=\; 1.5 : 1 \;=\; \frac{3}{2} : 1 \;=\; 3 : 2.

So, 3 cups of water have been mixed with 2 cups of pure milk.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Abnormal molar mass and van't Hoff factor. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
ChapterSolutions
TopicAbnormal molar mass and van't Hoff factor
TypeMultiple choice