RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 12 APR S1+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Alkaline earth metals: properties and trends

The correct sequence of thermal stability of the following carbonates is:

SOLUTION

We wish to arrange the carbonates of the alkaline-earth metals Mg, Ca, Sr and Ba in the order of their thermal stability, that is, the ease with which they resist decomposition on heating:

MCO3  ⟶  MO  +  CO2\text{MCO}_3 \; \longrightarrow \; \text{MO} \;+\; \text{CO}_2

Higher thermal stability means a higher temperature is required for the above decomposition, whereas lower thermal stability means the salt breaks up more readily.

First, we recall the Fajan’s rule statement: “The smaller the cation and the larger its charge, the greater its polarising power, and hence the greater the covalent character of the compound.” Conversely, a larger cation possesses lower polarising power, thereby creating a more ionic lattice.

Now, for the alkaline-earth metals in the order

Mg2+,  Ca2+,  Sr2+,  Ba2+\text{Mg}^{2+},\; \text{Ca}^{2+},\; \text{Sr}^{2+},\; \text{Ba}^{2+}

we note that ionic radius increases as we move down the group. Because the charge +2+2 is the same for all of them, the polarising power depends only on the size. Hence

polarising power:  Mg2+  >  Ca2+  >  Sr2+  >  Ba2+\text{polarising power:}\; \text{Mg}^{2+} \;>\; \text{Ca}^{2+} \;>\; \text{Sr}^{2+} \;>\; \text{Ba}^{2+}

Greater polarising power distorts the electron cloud of the carbonate ion CO32−\text{CO}_3^{2-} more strongly, weakening the C-O\text{C-O} bonds and facilitating decomposition. Therefore, the carbonate with the smallest cation (MgCO3_3) is the least thermally stable, while the carbonate with the largest cation (BaCO3_3) is the most thermally stable.

Writing this out explicitly, we obtain

thermal stability:  MgCO3  <  CaCO3  <  SrCO3  <  BaCO3\text{thermal stability:}\; \text{MgCO}_3 \;<\; \text{CaCO}_3 \;<\; \text{SrCO}_3 \;<\; \text{BaCO}_3

We now simply match this derived sequence with the alternatives provided:

Option A states: BaCO3<CaCO3<SrCO3<MgCO3\text{BaCO}_3 < \text{CaCO}_3 < \text{SrCO}_3 < \text{MgCO}_3 - this is the reverse of what we derived; it is incorrect.

Option B states: MgCO3<CaCO3<SrCO3<BaCO3\text{MgCO}_3 < \text{CaCO}_3 < \text{SrCO}_3 < \text{BaCO}_3 - this exactly matches our result; it is correct.

Option C and Option D similarly disagree with the correct order.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Alkaline earth metals: properties and trends. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicAlkaline earth metals: properties and trends
TypeMultiple choice