The correct sequence of thermal stability of the following carbonates is:
We wish to arrange the carbonates of the alkaline-earth metals Mg, Ca, Sr and Ba in the order of their thermal stability, that is, the ease with which they resist decomposition on heating:
Higher thermal stability means a higher temperature is required for the above decomposition, whereas lower thermal stability means the salt breaks up more readily.
First, we recall the Fajan’s rule statement: “The smaller the cation and the larger its charge, the greater its polarising power, and hence the greater the covalent character of the compound.” Conversely, a larger cation possesses lower polarising power, thereby creating a more ionic lattice.
Now, for the alkaline-earth metals in the order
we note that ionic radius increases as we move down the group. Because the charge is the same for all of them, the polarising power depends only on the size. Hence
Greater polarising power distorts the electron cloud of the carbonate ion more strongly, weakening the bonds and facilitating decomposition. Therefore, the carbonate with the smallest cation (MgCO) is the least thermally stable, while the carbonate with the largest cation (BaCO) is the most thermally stable.
Writing this out explicitly, we obtain
We now simply match this derived sequence with the alternatives provided:
Option A states: - this is the reverse of what we derived; it is incorrect.
Option B states: - this exactly matches our result; it is correct.
Option C and Option D similarly disagree with the correct order.
Hence, the correct answer is Option B.
Tagged Alkaline earth metals: properties and trends. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.