RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2013 · 09 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2013 Chemistry question — Group analysis and confirmatory tests of cations

Sodium Carbonate cannot be used in place of (NH4)2CO3(NH_4)_2CO_3 for the identification of Ca2+Ca^{2+}, Ba2+Ba^{2+} and Sr2+Sr^{2+} ions (in group V) during mixture analysis because :

SOLUTION

In qualitative inorganic analysis for group V cations, which include calcium (Ca2+Ca^{2+}), barium (Ba2+Ba^{2+}), and strontium (Sr2+Sr^{2+}), we precipitate them as carbonates using ammonium carbonate ((NH4)2CO3(NH_4)_2CO_3). The question asks why sodium carbonate (Na2CO3Na_2CO_3) cannot be used instead.

First, consider the precipitation reaction. The carbonate ion (CO32−CO_3^{2-}) reacts with these metal ions to form insoluble carbonates:

Ca2++CO32−→CaCO3↓Ca^{2+} + CO_3^{2-} \rightarrow CaCO_3 \downarrow

Ba2++CO32−→BaCO3↓Ba^{2+} + CO_3^{2-} \rightarrow BaCO_3 \downarrow

Sr2++CO32−→SrCO3↓Sr^{2+} + CO_3^{2-} \rightarrow SrCO_3 \downarrow

However, if we use sodium carbonate (Na2CO3Na_2CO_3), it dissociates completely in water:

Na2CO3→2Na++CO32−Na_2CO_3 \rightarrow 2Na^+ + CO_3^{2-}

This provides a high concentration of carbonate ions (CO32−CO_3^{2-}). Magnesium ion (Mg2+Mg^{2+}), which belongs to group IV, is not supposed to precipitate in group V. But magnesium carbonate (MgCO3MgCO_3) is sparingly soluble and can precipitate if the carbonate ion concentration is sufficiently high:

Mg2++CO32−→MgCO3↓Mg^{2+} + CO_3^{2-} \rightarrow MgCO_3 \downarrow

Ammonium carbonate ((NH4)2CO3(NH_4)_2CO_3) is used instead because it contains ammonium ions (NH4+NH_4^+). These ions suppress the carbonate ion concentration by reacting with it:

CO32−+NH4+→HCO3−+NH3CO_3^{2-} + NH_4^+ \rightarrow HCO_3^- + NH_3

This reaction reduces the concentration of CO32−CO_3^{2-} ions, making it insufficient to precipitate MgCO3MgCO_3 (since MgCO3MgCO_3 has a higher solubility product compared to the carbonates of Ca2+Ca^{2+}, Ba2+Ba^{2+}, and Sr2+Sr^{2+}). Thus, Mg2+Mg^{2+} remains in solution and is not precipitated in group V.

In contrast, sodium carbonate does not provide any suppressing ions. The sodium ions (Na+Na^+) do not react with carbonate ions and do not reduce their concentration. Therefore, the high CO32−CO_3^{2-} concentration from Na2CO3Na_2CO_3 causes Mg2+Mg^{2+} to precipitate as MgCO3MgCO_3 along with the group V cations.

Now, evaluating the options:

Option A states that Mg2+Mg^{2+} ions will also be precipitated. This aligns with our reasoning, as the high carbonate concentration from sodium carbonate leads to unwanted precipitation of magnesium carbonate.

Option B claims the concentration of CO32−CO_3^{2-} ions is very low. This is incorrect because sodium carbonate provides a high concentration of CO32−CO_3^{2-} ions due to complete dissociation.

Option C suggests sodium ions react with acid radicals. Sodium ions (Na+Na^+) are inert and do not react with acid radicals in a way that affects the precipitation of group V cations.

Option D says Na+Na^+ ions interfere with the detection of Ca2+Ca^{2+}, Ba2+Ba^{2+}, Sr2+Sr^{2+}. Sodium ions do not form insoluble compounds and do not interfere directly; the issue is the precipitation of Mg2+Mg^{2+}.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Group analysis and confirmatory tests of cations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGroup analysis and confirmatory tests of cations
TypeMultiple choice