During the detection of acidic radical present in a salt, a student gets a pale yellow precipitate soluble with difficulty in solution when sodium carbonate extract was first acidified with dil. and then solution was added. This indicates presence of :
We need to identify the acidic radical that gives a pale yellow precipitate soluble with difficulty in NHOH when tested with AgNO. When the sodium carbonate extract of a salt is acidified with dilute HNO and treated with AgNO, the halide ions form silver halide precipitates with characteristic colours and solubilities: AgCl (from Cl) gives a white curdy precipitate easily soluble in dilute NHOH (forms soluble [Ag(NH)]Cl), AgBr (from Br) gives a pale yellow precipitate soluble with difficulty in NHOH (partially soluble, requires concentrated NHOH), and AgI (from I) gives a yellow precipitate insoluble in NHOH.
Since the observed precipitate is pale yellow, Cl is ruled out and Br is consistent; moreover, its solubility with difficulty in NHOH matches AgBr, whereas AgI would be completely insoluble and AgCl would dissolve easily.
Furthermore, CO would not give a precipitate with AgNO in acidic medium, as it reacts with acid to form CO, eliminating Option (4).
The correct answer is Option (1): Br.
Tagged Analysis of anions. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.