Which of the following statements is incorrect?
First, let us recall the well-known qualitative test that produces a characteristic blood-red colour. The ion responsible for this colour is the ferric ion when it reacts with the thiocyanate ion . The reaction can be written as
The complex (and related higher thiocyanato complexes such as ) has an intense blood-red colour. Thus, whenever we see the test tube turning blood red on addition of , the presence of is indicated.
Now we examine each statement one by one, keeping this fact in mind.
Statement A says: “ ion also gives blood red colour with ion.”
But we know from the reaction above that the ferrous ion does not form the deeply coloured thiocyanato complex. Instead, either remains colourless/pale green or may very slowly get oxidised to in air and then show the colour. Directly, however, does not give the blood-red colour. Hence Statement A is false.
Statement B says: “ ion also gives blood red colour with ion.”
As just discussed, this is exactly the classical test for , so Statement B is true.
Statement C says: “On passing into solution, a white precipitate of is formed.”
Let us write the ionic equation. The zincate ion present is . Passing through the alkaline solution first neutralises the basicity and then gives the sulphide:
The precipitate is white. Therefore Statement C is true.
Statement D says: “Cupric ion reacts with excess of ammonia solution to give a deep blue colour of ion.”
The well-known complex-formation reaction is
The tetraamminecuprate(II) ion is indeed deep blue, so Statement D is true.
Putting it all together, only Statement A is incorrect.
Hence, the correct answer is Option A.
Tagged Group analysis and confirmatory tests of cations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.