RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2015 · 10 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2015 Chemistry question — Group analysis and confirmatory tests of cations

The cation that will not be precipitated by H2SH_2S in the presence of dil HCl is:

SOLUTION

First, let us recall the basic idea used in salt-analysis. The precipitation of metal sulphides is brought about by passing hydrogen sulphide gas H2SH_2S through the solution containing the cation. The required sulphide ion concentration [S2−][S^{2-}] is obtained from the dissociation

H2S  ⇌  2H+  +  S2−H_2S \; \rightleftharpoons \; 2H^+ \;+\; S^{2-}

The equilibrium expression is

Ka=[H+]2 [S2−][H2S].K_a = \dfrac{[H^+]^2\,[S^{2-}]}{[H_2S]}.

Now, if we add dilute hydrochloric acid, we increase [H+][H^+]. According to Le-Chatelier’s principle the equilibrium shifts to the left, thereby decreasing [S2−][S^{2-}]. Only those metal ions whose sulphides have extremely small solubility-product constants KspK_{sp} can still get the necessary S2−S^{2-} and precipitate in this acidic medium. These ions constitute Group II of qualitative analysis.

The two sub-groups of Group II are

Group II A : Cu2+, Cd2+, Pb2+, Bi3+, Hg2+ (Cu^{2+},\, Cd^{2+},\, Pb^{2+},\, Bi^{3+},\, Hg^{2+}\ ( and similar ))

Group II B : As3+, As5+, Sb3+, Sb5+, Sn2+, Sn4+.As^{3+},\, As^{5+},\, Sb^{3+},\, Sb^{5+},\, Sn^{2+},\, Sn^{4+}.

All of these have very low KspK_{sp} values for their sulphides, so they are precipitated by H2SH_2S even in the presence of dilute HClHCl.

Let us now examine the cations given in the options:

Option A :Co2+Option B :As3+Option C :Pb2+Option D :Cu2+\begin{aligned} \text{Option A } & : Co^{2+} \\ \text{Option B } & : As^{3+} \\ \text{Option C } & : Pb^{2+} \\ \text{Option D } & : Cu^{2+} \end{aligned}

Co2+Co^{2+} belongs to Group IV. The sulphide CoSCoS has a comparatively large solubility-product constant. In the acidic medium produced by dilute HClHCl, the concentration [S2−][S^{2-}] becomes far smaller than that required to exceed Ksp(CoS)K_{sp}(CoS). Hence the ionic product

I.P=[Co2+] [S2−]I.P = [Co^{2+}]\,[S^{2-}]

never reaches Ksp(CoS)K_{sp}(CoS) and no precipitate forms.

In contrast, As3+, Pb2+As^{3+},\, Pb^{2+} and Cu2+Cu^{2+} all have sulphides with such tiny KspK_{sp} values that even the suppressed [S2−][S^{2-}] in acidic medium is enough to satisfy

[Mn+] [S2−]≥Ksp(MS)[M^{n+}]\,[S^{2-}] \ge K_{sp}(MS)

and their sulphides As2S3, PbS,As_2S_3,\, PbS, and CuSCuS respectively do precipitate.

Therefore, among the four ions only Co2+Co^{2+} fails to precipitate with H2SH_2S in the presence of dilute HClHCl.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Group analysis and confirmatory tests of cations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGroup analysis and confirmatory tests of cations
TypeMultiple choice