The cation that will not be precipitated by in the presence of dil HCl is:
First, let us recall the basic idea used in salt-analysis. The precipitation of metal sulphides is brought about by passing hydrogen sulphide gas through the solution containing the cation. The required sulphide ion concentration is obtained from the dissociation
The equilibrium expression is
Now, if we add dilute hydrochloric acid, we increase . According to Le-Chatelier’s principle the equilibrium shifts to the left, thereby decreasing . Only those metal ions whose sulphides have extremely small solubility-product constants can still get the necessary and precipitate in this acidic medium. These ions constitute Group II of qualitative analysis.
The two sub-groups of Group II are
Group II A : and similar
Group II B :
All of these have very low values for their sulphides, so they are precipitated by even in the presence of dilute .
Let us now examine the cations given in the options:
belongs to Group IV. The sulphide has a comparatively large solubility-product constant. In the acidic medium produced by dilute , the concentration becomes far smaller than that required to exceed . Hence the ionic product
never reaches and no precipitate forms.
In contrast, and all have sulphides with such tiny values that even the suppressed in acidic medium is enough to satisfy
and their sulphides and respectively do precipitate.
Therefore, among the four ions only fails to precipitate with in the presence of dilute .
Hence, the correct answer is Option A.
Tagged Group analysis and confirmatory tests of cations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.