In the Carius method we directly obtain the mass of halogen present. Here,
Mass of compound taken=0.172 g
Mass of bromine found=0.080 g
We first calculate the percentage of bromine in the unknown sample. The general relation is
%Br=mass of samplemass of Br obtained×100
Substituting the given numbers,
%Br=0.1720.080×100
%Br=0.465116…×100
%Br=46.5116%≈46.5%
Now we compare this experimental value with the theoretical bromine percentages of each option. For every structure we first write its molecular formula, then its molar mass, and finally the percentage of bromine.
Option A : CH3CHBr2
Molecular formula: C2H4Br2
Molar mass:
M=2(12)+4(1)+2(79.9)=24+4+159.8=187.8 g mol−1
Theoretical bromine percentage:
%Br=187.82(79.9)×100=187.8159.8×100=85.06%
This is far higher than the required 46.5%, so Option A is rejected.
Option B : p-bromoaniline
Molecular formula: an aniline ring C6H5NH2 with one Br substituent gives C6H6BrN.
Molar mass:
M=6(12)+6(1)+79.9+14=72+6+79.9+14=171.9 g mol−1
Theoretical bromine percentage:
%Br=171.979.9×100=46.509%≈46.5%
This matches the experimental value almost exactly.
Option C : 3,5-dibromoaniline
Molecular formula: C6H5Br2N
Molar mass:
M=6(12)+5(1)+2(79.9)+14=72+5+159.8+14=250.8 g mol−1
Theoretical bromine percentage:
%Br=250.8159.8×100=63.74%
This value is much higher than 46.5%, so Option C is also ruled out.
Option D : H3CCH2Br
Molecular formula: C2H5Br
Molar mass:
M=2(12)+5(1)+79.9=24+5+79.9=108.9 g mol−1
Theoretical bromine percentage:
%Br=108.979.9×100=73.40%
Again this is far above 46.5%, so Option D is discarded.
Only p-bromoaniline shows a bromine percentage that coincides with the experimental value. Therefore the unknown compound must be p-bromoaniline.
Hence, the correct answer is Option B.