Two compounds I and II are eluted by column chromatography (adsorption of I > II). Which one of the following is a correct statement?
We are told that, in column chromatography, compound I is adsorbed more strongly than compound II, i.e.
In column chromatography the stationary phase is an adsorbent, often silica or alumina. A greater degree of adsorption means a stronger interaction with the stationary phase, so the compound travels down the column more slowly. Conversely, a compound that is adsorbed less strongly interacts weakly with the stationary phase and is carried downward more quickly by the mobile phase.
Therefore, because I is more strongly adsorbed, I moves slower through the column, while II, being less strongly adsorbed, moves faster.
Now let us connect this to the value, which is defined (for thin-layer chromatography, but the qualitative trend is the same) as
If a compound travels a larger distance on the plate (or equivalently elutes faster in a column), the numerator in the above fraction is larger, giving a higher . Thus, the compound that moves faster automatically acquires the higher value.
Since we have already established that II moves faster than I, it must also have the higher value.
Putting the two conclusions together:
• II moves faster than I, and
• II has the higher value.
This statement matches exactly with Option B.
Hence, the correct answer is Option B.
Tagged Methods of purification of organic compounds. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.