In which one of the following molecules strongest back donation of an electron pair from halide to boron is expected?
We have four boron trihalides: . In every one of these molecules the central boron atom possesses only six valence electrons, so it is electron-deficient and can accept electron density. Each halogen atom, on the other hand, has three lone pairs and can donate one of those lone pairs into the empty orbital of boron. This donation of a filled orbital on the halogen into an empty orbital on boron is called back bonding (or back donation when both orbitals are orbitals).
The strength of such back donation depends primarily on the efficiency of orbital overlap. The guiding principle is:
For boron, the relevant empty orbital is the orbital. Therefore the ideal donor would also have a orbital, because orbitals of the same principal quantum number (and therefore similar size and energy) overlap most effectively. Let us compare each halogen:
• In the lone pair resides in a orbital (same principal quantum number as boron’s ).
• In the lone pair is in a orbital (larger and higher in energy than ).
• In the lone pair is in a orbital (even larger and higher in energy).
• In the lone pair is in a orbital (largest mismatch of all).
Because the radial size and energy separation between and orbitals are minimal, the overlap in is far superior to that in the other trihalides. As the halogen becomes heavier (from F to I) the difference in size and energy between its lone-pair orbital and boron’s empty orbital keeps increasing, so the overlap - and hence the back donation - keeps weakening.
Therefore the order of back-bond strength is
So the molecule with the strongest halide → boron back donation is , which corresponds to option 4.
Hence, the correct answer is Option 4.
Tagged Group 13: general trends and inert pair effect. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.