RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 25 JUL S1+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Chemistry question — Group 14: trends and carbon allotropes

Which one of the following compounds of Group-14 elements is not known?

SOLUTION

First, we recall that the Group-14 elements are C, Si, Ge, Sn, Pb\text{C, Si, Ge, Sn, Pb}. In these elements the common higher oxidation state is +4+4, and many of their complex anions can be viewed as having the general formula [EX6]2−[\text{E}X_6]^{2-} where every ligand XX carries a charge −1-1.

To see whether a particular hexacoordinate ion is possible, we examine two points:

(i) the oxidation state balance We write the usual charge-balance equation 6(−1)+(oxidation state of E)=−2.6(-1) + (\text{oxidation state of E}) = -2. Solving, we have oxidation state of E=+4.\text{oxidation state of E} = +4. So for every choice of central atom E\text{E} the required oxidation state is indeed the normal +4+4, which is accessible to Si, Ge\text{Si, Ge} and Sn\text{Sn}. Hence charge balance causes no difficulty for any of the listed species.

(ii) the steric (size) requirement for an octahedral arrangement In an octahedral [EX6]2−[\text{E}X_6]^{2-} ion all six ligands must crowd around the central atom. The larger the ligands, the more space they demand; the larger the central atom, the more easily it can accommodate them. Fluoride F−F^- is the smallest normal monodentate ligand, chloride Cl−Cl^- is appreciably larger, and hydroxide OH−OH^- lies in between. Among the central atoms, the size trend is r(Si)<r(Ge)<r(Sn).r(\text{Si}) \lt r(\text{Ge}) \lt r(\text{Sn}).

Now we check each option in turn.

Option A : [GeCl6]2−[\text{GeCl}_6]^{2-}. Germanium is larger than silicon, so six chloride ions can fit around it. Indeed, hexachlorogermanate(IV) salts such as K2[GeCl6]\text{K}_2[\text{GeCl}_6] are known. Therefore this ion exists.

Option B : [Sn(OH)6]2−[\text{Sn(OH)}_6]^{2-}. Tin(IV) is the largest central atom among the ones listed, and hydroxide is smaller than chloride. The well-known stannate ion [Sn(OH)6]2−[\text{Sn(OH)}_6]^{2-} (or its oxide form SnO32−\text{SnO}_3^{2-} after dehydration) is easily formed in alkali. Thus this species also exists.

Option C : [SiCl6]2−[\text{SiCl}_6]^{2-}. Here the problem is spatial. Silicon is the smallest of the three possible centres, while chloride is relatively bulky. Trying to pack six Cl−Cl^- ions around the small Si4+\text{Si}^{4+} produces prohibitive ligand-ligand repulsion, so the octahedral complex cannot be stabilised. No salts of the “hexachlorosilicate(IV)” ion are known.

Option D : [SiF6]2−[\text{SiF}_6]^{2-}. Although silicon is small, fluoride is even smaller, allowing the required octahedral arrangement. The ion [SiF6]2−[\text{SiF}_6]^{2-} is perfectly stable; commercial compounds such as Na2[SiF6]\text{Na}_2[\text{SiF}_6] (sodium hexafluorosilicate) are common.

Therefore, among the four species, the only one that cannot exist is [SiCl6]2−[\text{SiCl}_6]^{2-}.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Group 14: trends and carbon allotropes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGroup 14: trends and carbon allotropes
TypeMultiple choice