Which one of the following compounds of Group-14 elements is not known?
First, we recall that the Group-14 elements are . In these elements the common higher oxidation state is , and many of their complex anions can be viewed as having the general formula where every ligand carries a charge .
To see whether a particular hexacoordinate ion is possible, we examine two points:
(i) the oxidation state balance We write the usual charge-balance equation Solving, we have So for every choice of central atom the required oxidation state is indeed the normal , which is accessible to and . Hence charge balance causes no difficulty for any of the listed species.
(ii) the steric (size) requirement for an octahedral arrangement In an octahedral ion all six ligands must crowd around the central atom. The larger the ligands, the more space they demand; the larger the central atom, the more easily it can accommodate them. Fluoride is the smallest normal monodentate ligand, chloride is appreciably larger, and hydroxide lies in between. Among the central atoms, the size trend is
Now we check each option in turn.
Option A : . Germanium is larger than silicon, so six chloride ions can fit around it. Indeed, hexachlorogermanate(IV) salts such as are known. Therefore this ion exists.
Option B : . Tin(IV) is the largest central atom among the ones listed, and hydroxide is smaller than chloride. The well-known stannate ion (or its oxide form after dehydration) is easily formed in alkali. Thus this species also exists.
Option C : . Here the problem is spatial. Silicon is the smallest of the three possible centres, while chloride is relatively bulky. Trying to pack six ions around the small produces prohibitive ligand-ligand repulsion, so the octahedral complex cannot be stabilised. No salts of the “hexachlorosilicate(IV)” ion are known.
Option D : . Although silicon is small, fluoride is even smaller, allowing the required octahedral arrangement. The ion is perfectly stable; commercial compounds such as (sodium hexafluorosilicate) are common.
Therefore, among the four species, the only one that cannot exist is .
Hence, the correct answer is Option C.
Tagged Group 14: trends and carbon allotropes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.