Boron cannot form which one of the following anions?
Boron is in Period 2 of the periodic table. Hence:
• Its valence shell is the second shell (n = 2).
• The maximum set of valence orbitals available is one 2s orbital and three 2p orbitals (total 4).
• There are no 2d orbitals of comparable energy, so boron cannot expand its octet beyond 8 electrons and cannot attain a coordination number greater than 4.
Now examine each anion:
Case A:
This is the tetrahydroborate ion. Boron uses its four valence orbitals to form four bonds with H, giving a tetrahedral arrangement. Coordination number = 4, which is possible. So this anion is stable and known (e.g. in ).
Case B:
Here boron again forms four bonds (one to each OH group). Coordination number = 4, within the octet limit. The anion exists in alkaline solutions of boric acid. Hence it can be formed.
Case C:
This is metaborate. Boron is three-coordinate here (one double-bond equivalent to O and two single B-O bonds aggregated in polymeric forms). Coordination number = 3, easily accommodated. The ion exists in many borate salts such as .
Case D:
To surround boron with six fluoride ligands, a coordination number = 6 is required. Achieving a hexacoordinate environment needs six hybrid orbitals (usually ), which in turn demand the participation of d-orbitals. Because boron belongs to the second period, there are no 2d orbitals of suitable energy, so it cannot expand its octet to accommodate six F ligands. Consequently such anion cannot be formed.
Therefore boron is unable to form , while all the other listed anions are known.
Option D which is:
Tagged Boron compounds. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.