RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 16 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Chemistry question — Group 13: general trends and inert pair effect

A group 13 element 'X' reacts with chlorine gas to produce a compound XCl3_3. XCl3_3 is electron deficient and easily reacts with NH3_3 to form Cl3_3X ←\leftarrow NH3_3 adduct; however, XCl3_3 does not dimerize. X is:

SOLUTION

We have element XX belonging to group 13, so the possible elements are B, Al, Ga, In, Tl\text{B, Al, Ga, In, Tl}. The question tells us that XX reacts with chlorine gas to give the trichloride XCl3\text{XCl}_3.

Now, the given properties of XCl3\text{XCl}_3 are:

(i) XCl3\text{XCl}_3 is electron-deficient. (ii) It readily accepts a lone pair from NH3\text{NH}_3 to form the Lewis-acid-base adduct Cl3X←NH3\text{Cl}_3X \leftarrow \text{NH}_3. (iii) It does not dimerize.

First recall the concept of electron deficiency. A molecule is electron deficient when the central atom has fewer than eight electrons in its valence shell. All group-13 trihalides MX3\text{MX}_3 (where M = B, Al, Ga, In, Tl\text{M = B, Al, Ga, In, Tl}) possess only 66 valence electrons around the metal, so they are potential Lewis acids. Thus condition (i) is satisfied by every MCl3\text{MCl}_3 in the list.

Next, we use the experimentally observed tendency toward dimerization. A larger central atom can expand its coordination number by employing vacant pp orbitals to accept electron density from chloride bridges, leading to the dimer:

2 MCl3    ⟶    Cl3M ⁣− ⁣ ⁣ ⁣    Cl   ⁣− ⁣ ⁣ ⁣    MCl32\,\text{MCl}_3 \;\; \longrightarrow \;\; \text{Cl}_3\text{M}\!-\!\!\!\;\:\,\text{Cl}\;\!-\!\!\!\;\:\,\text{MCl}_3

The accepted textbook facts are:

• BCl3\text{BCl}_3 remains monomeric in the vapour and in non-coordinating solvents because the boron atom is too small to accommodate two extra chloride bridges. • AlCl3,GaCl3,\text{AlCl}_3, \text{GaCl}_3, and InCl3\text{InCl}_3 dimerize to M2Cl6\text{M}_2\text{Cl}_6 in the gaseous state or in solution unless a stronger base is present.

Therefore the information that XCl3\text{XCl}_3 does not dimerize singles out boron trichloride:

BCl3  (monomeric),AlCl3→(Al2Cl6),  GaCl3→(Ga2Cl6),  InCl3→(In2Cl6)\text{BCl}_3 \; ( \text{monomeric} ) , \qquad \text{AlCl}_3 \to \text{(Al}_2\text{Cl}_6), \; \text{GaCl}_3 \to \text{(Ga}_2\text{Cl}_6), \; \text{InCl}_3 \to \text{(In}_2\text{Cl}_6)

Finally, statement (ii) about forming the adduct Cl3X←NH3\text{Cl}_3X \leftarrow \text{NH}_3 is perfectly consistent with BCl3\text{BCl}_3, which is the classic Lewis acid that picks up the nitrogen lone pair:

BCl3+NH3    ⟶    Cl3B←NH3\text{BCl}_3 + \text{NH}_3 \;\; \longrightarrow \;\; \text{Cl}_3\text{B} \leftarrow \text{NH}_3

So every given property matches X=Boron (B)X = \text{Boron (B)} and none of the heavier group-13 elements satisfy the “no dimerization” condition.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Group 13: general trends and inert pair effect. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGroup 13: general trends and inert pair effect
TypeMultiple choice