RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 12 JAN S2+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Group 14: trends and carbon allotropes

The element that shows greater ability to form pπ−pπp\pi - p\pi multiple bonds is:

SOLUTION

First, let us list the four elements once again: C (carbon), Si (silicon), Ge (germanium), Sn (tin). All of them belong to Group 14 of the periodic table and each possesses the general outer-shell configuration ns2np2.ns^2np^2.

Now, the ability to create a pπ−pπp\pi - p\pi multiple bond (for example C=CC=C or C#CC{\#}C) depends mainly on two related factors: the effective sideways (lateral) overlap between two pp orbitals, and the matching in energy of those pp orbitals. For good overlap, the orbitals must be (i) sufficiently small and (ii) held close to the nucleus so that their lobes meet accurately in space.

Moving down the group from C\text{C} to Sn,\text{Sn}, we have an increase in principal quantum number nn: the pp orbitals change successively from 2p2p to 3p3p to 4p4p to 5p.5p. A higher nn means:

Larger orbital radius    ⟹    more diffuse lobes.\text{Larger orbital radius} \;\; \Longrightarrow \;\; \text{more diffuse lobes}.

Diffuse lobes overlap less efficiently sideways, making the formation of strong pπ−pπp\pi - p\pi bonds increasingly difficult. Therefore the multiple-bond strength trend strictly decreases as we descend the group.

We can reinforce this idea by recalling observed chemistry:

C    readily forms  C=C,  C#C,  C=O,  C=N,etc.Si    rarely forms  Si=Si  (few compounds exist).Ge    forms Ge=Ge only under special conditions.Sn    virtually never shows Sn=Sn double bonds in simple molecules.\begin{aligned} \text{C} &\;\; \text{readily forms}\; C=C,\; C{\#}C,\; C=O,\; C=N, \text{etc.} \\ \text{Si} &\;\; \text{rarely forms}\; Si=Si\; (\text{few compounds exist}). \\ \text{Ge} &\;\; \text{forms Ge=Ge only under special conditions}. \\ \text{Sn} &\;\; \text{virtually never shows Sn=Sn double bonds in simple molecules}. \\ \end{aligned}

Hence, among the four, carbon’s 2p2p orbitals provide by far the best lateral overlap, giving it the greatest propensity toward multiple bonding via pπ−pπp\pi - p\pi interaction.

Thus the order of ability is

C>Si>Ge>Sn.\text{C} \gt \text{Si} \gt \text{Ge} \gt \text{Sn}.

Since the question asks for the element that shows greater ability (i.e., the greatest among those listed), the choice must be carbon.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Group 14: trends and carbon allotropes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGroup 14: trends and carbon allotropes
TypeMultiple choice