RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 12 JAN S2+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Group 14: trends and carbon allotropes

The element that does not show catenation is

SOLUTION

First, let us recall the meaning of the term “catenation”. Catenation is the self-linking property of an element through covalent bonds, resulting in chains or rings of identical atoms. Its extent depends mainly on the strength (bond enthalpy) of the element-element single bond. The higher the E_X−XE\_{X-X} bond enthalpy, the greater is the tendency toward catenation.

Now, we focus on the elements given in the options. All of them—Si,  Ge,  Sn,  Pb\text{Si},\; \text{Ge},\; \text{Sn},\; \text{Pb}—belong to group 1414 of the periodic table, lying below carbon. Down a group, the atomic size increases and the X ⁣− ⁣XX\!-\!X bond enthalpy decreases. Mathematically, we can summarise the trend:

EC-C  >  ESi-Si  >  EGe-Ge  >  ESn-Sn  >  EPb-PbE_{\text{C-C}} \; > \; E_{\text{Si-Si}} \; > \; E_{\text{Ge-Ge}} \; > \; E_{\text{Sn-Sn}} \; > \; E_{\text{Pb-Pb}}

The loss in bond strength arises because larger, more diffused orbitals overlap less efficiently, making the bond weaker and longer. As a consequence, the ability of the atoms to form stable chains falls sharply down the group.

Let us compare the approximate single-bond enthalpies (kJ mol−1) for clarity:

ESi-Si≈226,EGe-Ge≈188,ESn-Sn≈155,EPb-Pb≈110.\begin{aligned} E_{\text{Si-Si}} &\approx 226,\\ E_{\text{Ge-Ge}} &\approx 188,\\ E_{\text{Sn-Sn}} &\approx 155,\\ E_{\text{Pb-Pb}} &\approx 110. \end{aligned}

Because the Pb-Pb\text{Pb-Pb} bond is the weakest among these, two adjoining lead atoms cannot sustain a long chain. Therefore Pb\text{Pb} hardly exhibits catenation in ordinary chemical conditions. In contrast, silicon, germanium and even tin still possess sufficiently strong X ⁣− ⁣XX\!-\!X bonds to show at least limited catenation: polysilanes (SinH2n+2\text{Si}_n\text{H}_{2n+2}-type), polygermanes and stannanes (SnnH2n+2\text{Sn}_n\text{H}_{2n+2}-type) are all known.

Hence, among the given choices, lead is the element that does not show catenation.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Group 14: trends and carbon allotropes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGroup 14: trends and carbon allotropes
TypeMultiple choice