RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 11 JAN S2+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Aluminium and its compounds

The hydride that is NOT electron deficient is:

SOLUTION

First, let us recall the meaning of the term “electron-deficient hydride”. A hydride is called electron deficient when the central atom does not attain an octet of electrons in the usual two-electron covalent bonds and therefore needs multi-centre (3-centre-2-electron) bonding or some other delocalisation to hold the molecule together.

We will now examine each option one by one and count the electrons present around the central atom in the simple Lewis picture.

For a single ordinary covalent bond, the shared pair contains 22 electrons. To satisfy the octet rule, an atom ideally needs 88 electrons in its valence shell.

Option A : SiH4SiH_4

Silicon belongs to group 14, so its valence electron count is 44. In SiH4SiH_4 the silicon forms four Si-H single bonds. Each bond contributes 22 electrons to the valence shell of silicon. Hence the total number of electrons around silicon is

4 bonds×2 electrons per bond=8 electrons.4 \text{ bonds}\times 2 \text{ electrons per bond}=8 \text{ electrons}.

The octet is exactly satisfied, so SiH4SiH_4 is not electron deficient.

Option B : B2H6B_2H_6

Boron is in group 13 with 33 valence electrons. Even if each boron made three normal B-H bonds it would receive only 66 shared electrons, not 88. The actual structure of B2H6B_2H_6 contains two three-centre two-electron (3c-2e) B-H-B bridges to compensate for the deficiency. The presence of 3c-2e bonds is a hallmark of electron-deficient compounds, so B2H6B_2H_6 is electron deficient.

Option C : GaH3GaH_3

Gallium too is a group 13 element with 33 valence electrons. In GaH3GaH_3 the gallium would share 3×2=63\times 2 = 6 electrons, falling short of the octet. Like the other group-13 trihydrides, it is electron deficient (polymeric with bridge bonds in the solid state).

Option D : AlH3AlH_3

Aluminium is also a group 13 element. In monomeric AlH3AlH_3, aluminium would again receive only 66 electrons from the three Al-H bonds. To remedy this, AlH3AlH_3 forms polymeric chains with 3c-2e Al-H-Al bridges; therefore it is electron deficient.

From this detailed comparison we see that the only hydride in which the central atom achieves a complete octet through ordinary two-electron bonds is SiH4SiH_4.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Aluminium and its compounds. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicAluminium and its compounds
TypeMultiple choice