RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2016 · 10 APR ONLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2016 Chemistry question — Group 14: trends and carbon allotropes

Assertion: Among the carbon allotropes, diamond is an insulator, whereas, graphite is a good conductor of electricity.
Reason: Hybridization of carbon in diamond and graphite are sp3^3 and sp2^2 respectively.

SOLUTION

First, let us read the two statements with care.

Assertion: “Among the carbon allotropes, diamond is an insulator, whereas graphite is a good conductor of electricity.”

Reason: “Hybridization of carbon in diamond and graphite are sp3sp^3 and sp2sp^2 respectively.”

We want to judge two things: (i) whether each sentence is factually correct, and (ii) whether the second sentence is the real, complete cause for the first sentence. We shall proceed slowly, checking all the chemical facts step by step.

Step 1 - Verifying the assertion. In diamond every carbon is covalently bonded to four other carbons in a three-dimensional network. No free or mobile electrons are left. Therefore the electrical conductivity σ\sigma is practically zero; diamond is an insulator.
In graphite each carbon is covalently bonded to three other carbons in a two-dimensional hexagonal sheet. One valence electron of every carbon atom remains unbonded in a pzp_z orbital. These pzp_z orbitals overlap sideways over the whole sheet, producing a delocalised π\pi-electron cloud. These delocalised electrons can move under an electric field, so graphite conducts electricity well, especially along the planes. Hence the assertion is true.

Step 2 - Verifying the reason. The carbon in diamond has four σ\sigma-bonds arranged tetrahedrally. According to valence bond theory, tetrahedral geometry corresponds to sp3sp^3 hybridisation. In graphite the carbon forms only three σ\sigma-bonds lying in one plane at 120∘120^{\circ}. Planar trigonal geometry is obtained from sp2sp^2 hybridisation. Thus the reason is also true.

Step 3 - Testing whether the reason explains the assertion.
We now ask: “Does merely stating that the hybridisations are sp3sp^3 and sp2sp^2 automatically explain the difference in conductivity?”

  • Hybridisation describes how atomic orbitals mix to give bond geometry and bond type; it does not, by itself, mention free or delocalised electrons.
  • The actual cause of conductivity in graphite is the presence of one unhybridised pzp_z orbital per carbon whose electrons become delocalised to form a conduction band. Saying “graphite is sp2sp^2” certainly tells us there is an unhybridised pzp_z orbital, but the key phrase “delocalised π\pi electrons that are mobile” is missing. Similarly, the statement “diamond is sp3sp^3” only conveys tetrahedral bonding; it does not explicitly point out that all electrons are localised in σ\sigma-bonds and no conduction band exists.
  • Therefore, while the difference in hybridisation is related to the electronic structures, the reason as written is not a complete, explicit explanation of why one allotrope conducts and the other does not.

Because the assertion is correct, the reason is also correct, yet the reason does not sufficiently and directly explain the assertion, we select the option that says exactly this.

Option A states: “Both assertion and reason are correct, but the reason is not the correct explanation for the assertion.”

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Group 14: trends and carbon allotropes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGroup 14: trends and carbon allotropes
TypeMultiple choice