RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 04 SEP S1+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Refining of metals

Among statements (a) - (d), the correct ones are:
(a) Lime stone is decomposed to CaO during the extraction of iron from its oxides.
(b) In the extraction of silver, silver is extracted as an anionic complex.
(c) Nickel is purified by Mond's process.
(d) Zr and Ti are purified by Van Arkel method.

SOLUTION

We begin by recalling the basic facts connected with the common metallurgical processes mentioned in the four statements, then we check each one.

First, consider statement (a). In the blast-furnace extraction of iron, limestone, whose formula is CaCO3\text{CaCO}_3, is added as a flux. Inside the furnace the temperature gradually rises beyond ≈800∘C\approx 800^{\circ}\text{C}, and at that point limestone undergoes thermal decomposition. The decomposition reaction is stated as

CaCO3  → Δ   CaO+CO2↑.\text{CaCO}_3 \;\xrightarrow{\ \Delta\ }\; \text{CaO} + \text{CO}_2 \uparrow.

This freshly formed CaO\text{CaO} then reacts with the gangue (mainly SiO2\text{SiO}_2) to produce the fusible slag CaSiO3\text{CaSiO}_3. Because the first step definitely is the conversion of CaCO3\text{CaCO}_3 to CaO\text{CaO}, we see that statement (a) is correct.

Now we look at statement (b). Silver is commonly extracted from its sulphide ore (argentite, Ag2S\text{Ag}_2\text{S}) by the cyanide, or Mac-Arthur Forest, process. The key chemical step is the formation of a soluble anionic complex of silver with the cyanide ion. We write the balanced reaction in two stages.

First, the sulphide ore reacts with aqueous sodium cyanide and atmospheric oxygen (or hydrogen peroxide added in practice) to give the soluble complex:

Ag2S+4 NaCN+12 O2+H2O  ⟶  2 Na[Ag(CN)2]+Na2S+2 OH−.\text{Ag}_2\text{S} + 4\,\text{NaCN} + \tfrac{1}{2}\,\text{O}_2 + \text{H}_2\text{O} \;\longrightarrow\; 2\,\text{Na[Ag(CN)}_2] + \text{Na}_2\text{S} + 2\,\text{OH}^-.

The species [Ag(CN)2]−\text{[Ag(CN)}_2]^- is clearly an anionic complex of silver. Silver is later recovered from this solution by displacement with zinc, but the extraction indeed proceeds through an anionic complex. Hence statement (b) is also correct.

Next, examine statement (c). Mond’s process, also called the carbonyl process, is employed for the purification of nickel. The principle is the formation and subsequent decomposition of volatile nickel tetracarbonyl. We state the two crucial reactions.

Formation of the carbonyl at about 320 K:320\ \text{K}:

Ni(s)+4 CO(g)  ⇌  Ni(CO)4(g).\text{Ni}(s) + 4\,\text{CO}(g) \;\rightleftharpoons\; \text{Ni(CO)}_4(g).

Thermal decomposition of the carbonyl at about 450 K:450\ \text{K}:

Ni(CO)4(g)  → 450 K   Ni(s)+4 CO(g).\text{Ni(CO)}_4(g) \;\xrightarrow{\ 450\ \text{K}\ }\; \text{Ni}(s) + 4\,\text{CO}(g).

This sequence removes almost all impurities and gives extremely pure nickel, verifying that statement (c) is right.

Finally, consider statement (d). The Van Arkel (or iodide) method purifies certain transition metals that form volatile iodides and then revert to the pure metal on a hot filament. For titanium we write

Ti(impure)+2 I2  → 500 K   TiI4(g),\text{Ti}(impure) + 2\,\text{I}_2 \;\xrightarrow{\ 500\ \text{K}\ }\; \text{TiI}_4(g),

followed by

TiI4(g)  → 1800 K on hot W or Ti filament  Ti(pure)+2 I2.\text{TiI}_4(g) \;\xrightarrow{\ 1800\ \text{K}\ on\ hot\ W\ or\ Ti\ filament }\; \text{Ti}(pure) + 2\,\text{I}_2.

An analogous pair of reactions holds for zirconium:

Zr(impure)+2 I2  → 500 K   ZrI4(g),\text{Zr}(impure) + 2\,\text{I}_2 \;\xrightarrow{\ 500\ \text{K}\ }\; \text{ZrI}_4(g),

ZrI4(g)  → 1800 K  Zr(pure)+2 I2.\text{ZrI}_4(g) \;\xrightarrow{\ 1800\ \text{K} }\; \text{Zr}(pure) + 2\,\text{I}_2.

Because both Ti and Zr are indeed purified by this iodide route, statement (d) is correct.

We have now checked every statement, and all four—(a), (b), (c) and (d)—are correct.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Refining of metals. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.