RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2015 · 04 APR OFFLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2015 Chemistry question — Refining of metals

In the context of the Hall-Heroult process for the extraction of Al, which of the following statements is false?

SOLUTION

First, recall that in the Hall-Héroult electrolytic reduction of alumina, the electrolytic bath is not made of pure alumina. Pure Al2O3Al_2O_3 has an extremely high melting point, close to 2050∘C2050^\circ{\rm C}, and also possesses very low electrical conductivity in the molten state. To overcome these difficulties, a molten mixture is prepared which can both dissolve alumina and conduct current at a much lower temperature (about 950∘C950^\circ{\rm C}).

The principal constituent of this bath is molten cryolite, whose formula is Na3AlF6Na_3AlF_6. Alumina is added to this cryolite. To further decrease the melting point and improve conductivity, small amounts of CaF2CaF_2 are also mixed in. Thus the real electrolyte is the molten solution of alumina in cryolite (often with added CaF2CaF_2), not cryolite by itself.

We now examine each option:

Option A states, “Na3AlF6Na_3AlF_6 serves as the electrolyte.” Because the actual electrolyte is the mixture of Al2O3Al_2O_3 dissolved in molten Na3AlF6Na_3AlF_6 (sometimes with CaF2CaF_2), it is incorrect to say that cryolite alone is the electrolyte. Hence, this statement is false.

Option B claims that CO and CO2CO_2 are produced. At the carbon anode, oxide ions released from alumina react as

C (s) +2 O2−→CO2 + 4 e−\text{C (s) } + 2\,O^{2-} \rightarrow CO_2 \, + \, 4\,e^-

or, under slightly different conditions,

C (s) +O2−→CO + 2 e−\text{C (s) } + O^{2-} \rightarrow CO \, + \, 2\,e^-

Thus both CO and CO2CO_2 can indeed form, so Option B is true.

Option C says that Al2O3Al_2O_3 is mixed with CaF2CaF_2 which lowers the melting point of the mixture and provides conductivity. This effect of CaF2CaF_2 is well documented, so the statement is true.

Option D asserts that Al3+Al^{3+} ions are reduced at the cathode to metallic aluminium. At the cathode the reaction is

Al3+  +  3 e−  →  AlAl^{3+} \; + \; 3\,e^- \; \rightarrow \; Al

This is exactly what happens, so Option D is also true.

Only Option A is inconsistent with the detailed chemistry of the process.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Refining of metals. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.