RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2008TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2008 Chemistry question — Thermodynamic principles and Ellingham diagram

Which of the following factors is of no significance for roasting sulphide ores to the oxides and not subjecting the sulphide ores to carbon reduction directly?

SOLUTION

Roasting is the step in which a metal sulphide MSMS is first converted to its oxide MOMO by heating it in excess air :

2 MS+3 O2→2 MO+2 SO22\,MS + 3\,O_2 \rightarrow 2\,MO + 2\,SO_2

Only afterwards is the oxide reduced (most commonly by carbon/CO). We do not attempt a direct carbon-reduction of the sulphide

MS+C  ⟶  M+CS2  (or CS).MS + C \; \longrightarrow \; M + CS_2 \;(\text{or } CS).

The feasibility of any pyrometallurgical reaction is judged from the standard Gibbs energies of formation, which are plotted in an Ellingham diagram. Keeping this in mind, let us examine the four statements.

Case 1: Option B — CO2CO_2 is thermodynamically more stable than CS2CS_2

The line for CO2CO_2 lies far below that for CS2CS_2 on the Ellingham diagram, i.e. ΔGf∘(CO2)\Delta G_f^\circ(CO_2) is much more negative. Carbon therefore has a far greater affinity for oxygen than for sulphur. Hence carbon can reduce an oxide easily (because it is itself oxidised to CO2CO_2/COCO), but it cannot reduce a sulphide (because the oxidation product CS2CS_2 is much less stable). This factor is directly responsible for preferring roasting over direct carbon reduction, so Option B is significant.

Case 2: Option C — Metal sulphides are less stable than the corresponding oxides

For most metals the MOMO line also lies below the MSMS line. Consequently the conversion MS→MOMS \rightarrow MO (roasting) is spontaneous, often exothermic, and needs no external reducing agent. Thus Option C is again a valid reason for carrying out roasting.

Case 3: Option D — CO2CO_2 is more volatile than CS2CS_2

The gaseous product formed during reduction leaves the reaction mixture, driving the equilibrium to the right. CO2CO_2 (b.p. -78 °C under 1 atm) is far more volatile than CS2CS_2 (b.p. 46 °C). Therefore the removal of CO2CO_2 in oxide reduction is much easier than the removal of CS2CS_2 in a hypothetical sulphide reduction. This volatility factor also favours the oxide route, so Option D is significant.

Case 4: Option A — Metal sulphides are thermodynamically more stable than CS2CS_2

This statement compares two sulphur-containing species that are both on the sulphur side of the Ellingham diagram. Whether MSMS happens to be more or less stable than CS2CS_2 does not decide the success of carbon as a reducing agent; what really matters is the relative stabilities of the oxidation products of carbon (i.e. Option B) and of the ores themselves (i.e. Option C), together with the ease of removing the gaseous product (Option D). Hence the fact quoted in Option A is of no practical significance when deciding to roast the sulphide instead of reducing it directly with carbon.

Therefore, the factor that is not relevant for choosing roasting over direct carbon reduction is:

Option A which is: Metal sulphides are thermodynamically more stable than CS2CS_2.

Tagged Thermodynamic principles and Ellingham diagram. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicThermodynamic principles and Ellingham diagram
TypeMultiple choice