Which of the following reduction reaction CANNOT be carried out with coke?
The reduction of a metal oxide by coke (carbon) depends on the relative positions of the metal and carbon on the Ellingham diagram. Carbon can reduce a metal oxide only if the Gibbs free energy line for the formation of lies below the line for the metal oxide at the operating temperature.
Aluminium oxide () is extremely stable with a very large negative . On the Ellingham diagram, the line for lies well below the line for at all practical temperatures. This means carbon cannot reduce to aluminium. This is why aluminium is extracted industrially by electrolysis of molten alumina (Hall-Heroult process) rather than by carbon reduction.
In contrast, , , and can all be reduced by coke at sufficiently high temperatures, as their Ellingham diagram lines cross above the carbon line. Zinc is extracted by carbon reduction at about 1400°C, iron is produced in blast furnaces using coke, and copper oxide is easily reduced by carbon.
Therefore, the reduction that cannot be carried out with coke is , which is option (1).
Tagged Thermodynamic principles and Ellingham diagram. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.