RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2016 · 09 APR ONLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2016 Chemistry question — Water and heavy water

Identify the incorrect statement regarding heavy water:

SOLUTION

Let us first recall that heavy water is nothing but deuterium oxide, written as D2OD_2O. Wherever ordinary water H2OH_2O would react to give a hydrogen-containing product, heavy water behaves in exactly the same manner but now every hydrogen is replaced by deuterium DD. Using this guiding idea we can test each statement.

Option A: In ordinary water the well-known reaction is

H2O+SO3→H2SO4.H_2O + SO_3 \rightarrow H_2SO_4.

Replacing H2OH_2O by D2OD_2O we obtain

D2O+SO3→D2SO4.D_2O + SO_3 \rightarrow D_2SO_4.

This merely changes every HH to DD, so formation of deuterated sulphuric acid D2SO4D_2SO_4 is perfectly correct. Hence Option A is a correct statement.

Option B: Heavy water is famous for its ability to slow down (moderate) fast neutrons in a nuclear reactor. A moderator is a substance that decreases the energy of neutrons so that the nuclear chain reaction can be sustained. Although ordinary (light) water can serve as both coolant and moderator, heavy water is employed almost exclusively as a moderator; the coolant in most reactor designs is usually ordinary light water or some other fluid such as pressurised CO2 or liquid metal. Therefore the sentence “It is used as a coolant in nuclear reactors’’ is not generally correct for heavy water. So Option B is very likely to be the wrong statement.

Option C: With ordinary water the calcium carbide reaction is

CaC2+2 H2O→C2H2+Ca(OH)2.CaC_2 + 2\,H_2O \rightarrow C_2H_2 + Ca(OH)_2.

Writing H2OH_2O as D2OD_2O and replacing each hydrogen by deuterium we get

CaC2+2 D2O→C2D2+Ca(OD)2.CaC_2 + 2\,D_2O \rightarrow C_2D_2 + Ca(OD)_2.

This is exactly what Option C states, so Option C is correct.

Option D: For aluminium carbide with ordinary water the reaction is

Al4C3+12 H2O→3 CH4+4 Al(OH)3.Al_4C_3 + 12\,H_2O \rightarrow 3\,CH_4 + 4\,Al(OH)_3.

Substituting D2OD_2O for H2OH_2O and again changing every HH to DD we obtain

Al4C3+12 D2O→3 CD4+4 Al(OD)3.Al_4C_3 + 12\,D_2O \rightarrow 3\,CD_4 + 4\,Al(OD)_3.

Thus Option D is also fully correct.

From the above examination, only Option B makes an incorrect claim about the role of heavy water in a nuclear reactor.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Water and heavy water. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
ChapterHydrogen
TopicWater and heavy water
TypeMultiple choice