RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 27 JUL S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Chemistry question — Reactions of alkanes

Presence of which reagent will affect the reversibility of the following reaction, and change it to a irreversible reaction:
CH4+I2⇌hνReversibleCH3−I+HICH_4 + I_2 \underset{\text{Reversible}}{\overset{h\nu}{\rightleftharpoons}} CH_3 - I + HI

SOLUTION

First, let us recall why the photochemical iodination of methane is reversible. After the forward photochemical step

CH4+I2→hνCH3I+HI,CH_4 + I_2 \xrightarrow{h\nu} CH_3I + HI,

the hydrogen iodide that is formed is a very strong reducing agent. It immediately reacts back with the product methyl iodide and reproduces the starting materials:

CH3I+HI⟶CH4+I2.CH_3I + HI \longrightarrow CH_4 + I_2.

This back-reaction is fast, so the overall process settles at an equilibrium and the arrow becomes ⇌.\rightleftharpoons. To convert the system into an irreversible one we must remove, destroy or otherwise make HIHI unavailable as soon as it appears; then the reverse step cannot occur and the reaction will keep moving to the right until one of the reactants is exhausted.

Now we test each reagent given in the options to see whether it can do this job.

Option A : HOClHOCl (hypochlorous acid)
HOClHOCl can indeed oxidise iodide ions, but in doing so it itself gets reduced to HClHCl and water, and it works only under very dilute, neutral media. In the strongly acidic medium in which HIHI exists, HOClHOCl disproportionates rapidly and does not survive long enough to consume all the HIHI formed continuously in the photochemical reaction. Hence the equilibrium is not driven completely to the right.

Option B : dilute HNO2HNO_2 (nitrous acid)
HNO2HNO_2 is a mild oxidising agent. The reaction 2 HI+HNO2  ⟶  I2+NO+H2O2\,HI + HNO_2 \;\longrightarrow\; I_2 + NO + H_2O is slow and incomplete; the small amount of HIHI removed is quickly replenished by the back-reaction. Thus the system still remains reversible.

Option C : liquid NH3NH_3
Being a base, ammonia neutralises hydrogen iodide : NH3+HI  ⟶  NH4I.NH_3 + HI \;\longrightarrow\; NH_4I. Although free HIHI disappears, the iodide ion (I−)(I^-) that stays in the medium keeps reducing CH3ICH_3I by SN2S_N2 attack to reproduce methane: CH3I+I−  ⟶  CH3−+I2  ⟶  CH4+I2.CH_3I + I^- \;\longrightarrow\; CH_3^- + I_2 \;\longrightarrow\; CH_4 + I_2. Therefore the reverse path is still available and the reaction is not rendered irreversible.

Option D : concentrated HIO3HIO_3 (iodic acid)
Concentrated iodic acid is a much stronger oxidising agent for hydrogen iodide. The well-known redox reaction is

5 HI+HIO3  ⟶  3 I2+3 H2O.5\,HI + HIO_3 \;\longrightarrow\; 3\,I_2 + 3\,H_2O.

Observe each consequence carefully:

  • The freshly produced HIHI is immediately destroyed, so its concentration in the reaction vessel remains practically zero.
  • Because HIHI never accumulates, the reverse step CH3I+HI→CH4+I2CH_3I + HI \rightarrow CH_4 + I_2 becomes impossible.
  • The extra I2I_2 formed in the redox process simply joins the starting I2I_2 pool and continues to react with more CH4CH_4 under the influence of light, producing still more CH3ICH_3I. In other words, the presence of HIO3HIO_3 continuously pulls the overall reaction to the right.

Therefore, concentrated HIO3HIO_3 removes the key species HIHI as soon as it forms, blocking the backward path and converting the equilibrium into a one-way (irreversible) reaction.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Reactions of alkanes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicReactions of alkanes
TypeMultiple choice