Which of the following would not give 2-phenylbutane as the major product in a Friedel-Crafts alkylation reaction?
To solve this question, we need to determine which option does not produce 2-phenylbutane as the major product in a Friedel-Crafts alkylation reaction. Friedel-Crafts alkylation involves attaching an alkyl group to a benzene ring, forming a new carbon-carbon bond. The electrophile is typically a carbocation, which can rearrange to form a more stable carbocation. The target molecule, 2-phenylbutane, has the structure , where the carbon attached to the benzene ring is secondary.
Now, let's evaluate each option step by step.
Option A: 1-butene + HF
1-butene is . With HF, protonation occurs at the terminal carbon, forming a secondary carbocation: . This carbocation attacks benzene in a Friedel-Crafts alkylation, yielding , which is 2-phenylbutane. Thus, this option gives the desired product as the major product.
Option B: 2-butanol + HSO
2-butanol is . With HSO, dehydration occurs, protonating the hydroxyl group and losing water to form a secondary carbocation: . This carbocation attacks benzene, forming (2-phenylbutane). No rearrangement occurs, as the secondary carbocation is stable. Hence, this option gives 2-phenylbutane as the major product.
Option C: Butanoyl chloride + AlCl then Zn, HCl
Butanoyl chloride is . With AlCl, Friedel-Crafts acylation occurs, forming an acylium ion: . This electrophile attacks benzene, yielding the ketone (phenyl propyl ketone). The subsequent step, "then Zn, HCl", refers to Clemmensen reduction, which reduces the carbonyl group to a methylene group: (1-phenylbutane). This is a straight-chain alkylbenzene, whereas 2-phenylbutane is branched. Therefore, this option does not give 2-phenylbutane as the major product.
Option D: Butyl chloride + AlCl
Butyl chloride typically refers to n-butyl chloride, . With AlCl, it forms a primary carbocation: . Primary carbocations are unstable and rearrange via a hydride shift: (a more stable secondary carbocation). This carbocation attacks benzene, forming (2-phenylbutane). Due to rearrangement, this option gives 2-phenylbutane as the major product.
In summary, Options A, B, and D all yield 2-phenylbutane as the major product, while Option C yields 1-phenylbutane. Therefore, Option C does not give 2-phenylbutane as the major product.
Hence, the correct answer is Option C.
Tagged Electrophilic aromatic substitution. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.