RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 15 APR S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Chemistry question — Alkenes: preparation and stability

When 2-butyne is treated with H2_2/Lindlar's catalyst, compound X is produced as the major product and when treated with Na/liq. NH3_3 it produces Y as the major product. Which of the following statements is correct?

SOLUTION

We have the starting alkyne CH3−C≡C−CH3CH_{3}-C\equiv C-CH_{3}, whose IUPAC name is 2-butyne.

First we consider the reaction with H2H_{2} in the presence of Lindlar’s catalyst. The Lindlar system is a poisoned palladium catalyst that brings about syn addition of one molecule of hydrogen across the triple bond. The syn mode of addition places the two newly added hydrogens on the same side of the former π\pi-bond. As a result the product is the cis (Z) alkene:

CH3−C≡C−CH3⟶H2,  LindlarCH3-CH=CH-CH3  (cis)CH_{3}-C\equiv C-CH_{3} \overset{H_2,\;\text{Lindlar}}{\longrightarrow} \text{CH}_3\text{-CH}=\text{CH-CH}_3 \;(\text{cis})

Hence, the compound we call XX is cis-2-butene\text{cis-2-butene}.

Now we examine the reaction with metallic sodium in liquid ammonia, Na/liq.  NH3Na/liq.\;NH_{3}. This Birch-type reduction donates electrons in anti fashion, giving trans addition of hydrogen atoms across the alkyne. Consequently the product is the trans (E) alkene:

CH3−C≡C−CH3⟶Na,  liq. NH3CH3-CH=CH-CH3  (trans)CH_{3}-C\equiv C-CH_{3} \overset{Na,\;\text{liq. }NH_3}{\longrightarrow} \text{CH}_3\text{-CH}=\text{CH-CH}_3 \;(\text{trans})

Therefore, compound YY is trans-2-butene\text{trans-2-butene}.

Next we compare the physical properties of the two alkenes.

For dipole moment we recall that the molecular dipole μ\mu is the vector sum of all individual bond dipoles. In cis-2-butene\text{cis-2-butene} both C−CH3C-CH_{3} bond dipoles are oriented toward the same side of the double bond, so they reinforce each other and give a net dipole moment different from zero. In trans-2-butene\text{trans-2-butene} the molecule is planar and the two C−CH3C-CH_{3} bond dipoles lie in opposite directions, so they effectively cancel:

μcis>0,μtrans≈0\mu_{\text{cis}} \gt 0,\qquad \mu_{\text{trans}}\approx 0

Thus, XX (cis) has the higher dipole moment, while YY (trans) has the lower dipole moment.

Boiling point is influenced both by molecular mass and by intermolecular attractions. The masses are identical, so the decisive factor is the strength of the attractive forces. Because XX possesses a non-zero dipole, it exhibits dipole-dipole interactions in addition to London dispersion forces. These interactions raise its boiling point. In contrast, YY has almost no permanent dipole and relies mainly on dispersion forces, giving it a lower boiling point. Experimental data corroborate this reasoning:

b.p. of cis-2-butene  (X)≈3.7∘C\text{b.p. of cis-2-butene}\;(X)\approx 3.7^{\circ}\text{C}
b.p. of trans-2-butene  (Y)≈1.0∘C\text{b.p. of trans-2-butene}\;(Y)\approx 1.0^{\circ}\text{C}

So we conclude that XX possesses both the higher dipole moment and the higher boiling point relative to YY.

Among the given statements, only Option D matches this conclusion.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Alkenes: preparation and stability. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicAlkenes: preparation and stability
TypeMultiple choice