Which of the following potential energy (P.E.) diagrams represents the S1 reaction?
An substitution proceeds in TWO distinct steps:
1. Slow ionisation of the alkyl halide to give a carbocation and a halide ion.
2. Fast attack of the nucleophile on this carbocation.
Potential-energy consequences of these steps:
• Two elementary steps two transition states the energy profile must show TWO maxima.
• The first step (ionisation) is rate-determining, so its activation energy is larger; therefore the first maximum is higher than the second.
• Between the two maxima lies a local minimum that represents the carbocation intermediate.
Among the given diagrams, only Option A shows
• two humps (two transition states),
• the first hump higher than the second, and
• an intermediate valley between them.
Hence it correctly depicts the mechanism.
Option A which is: the diagram with two maxima (first higher) and a carbocation intermediate.
Tagged Nucleophilic substitution (SN1 and SN2). Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.