RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2017 · 09 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2017 Chemistry question — Nucleophilic substitution (SN1 and SN2)

In the following reaction sequence:

page12_img1


Compound I is

SOLUTION

We start with compound I, whose molecular formula is given as C3H6Cl2C_3H_6Cl_2. We need to decide which dichloropropane isomer it is. The whole decision will be based on the behaviour of the products formed in the subsequent steps.

First, I is treated with aqueous KOHKOH. A well-known result of treating a gem-dichloride (both chlorines on the same carbon) with aqueous alkali is hydrolysis to a gem-diol, which then immediately loses water to give a carbonyl compound. The overall transformation is

R2CCl2+2 KOH(aq)  →  R2C(OH)2+2 KClR_2CCl_2 + 2\,KOH_{(aq)} \;\rightarrow\; R_2C(OH)_2 + 2\,KCl

followed by

R2C(OH)2  →  R2C=O+H2OR_2C(OH)_2 \;\rightarrow\; R_2C=O + H_2O

If I were the gem-dichloride CH3−C(Cl)2−CH3CH_3-C(Cl)_2-CH_3 (2,2-dichloropropane), the reaction would be

CH3−C(Cl)2−CH3+2 KOH(aq)  →  CH3−C(OH)2−CH3+2 KClCH_3-C(Cl)_2-CH_3 + 2\,KOH_{(aq)} \;\rightarrow\; CH_3-C(OH)_2-CH_3 + 2\,KCl

and immediately

CH3−C(OH)2−CH3  →  CH3−CO−CH3+H2OCH_3-C(OH)_2-CH_3 \;\rightarrow\; CH_3-CO-CH_3 + H_2O

Thus compound II would be CH3−CO−CH3CH_3-CO-CH_3, that is, acetone (propan-2-one).

Now II is treated with methylmagnesium bromide and then hydrolysed. Before using the reagent, we recall the Grignard addition formula to a ketone:

R2C=O+R′MgX  →  R2C(OMgX)R′  ⟶H2O/H+  R2C(OH)R′+Mg(OH)XR_2C=O + R'MgX \;\rightarrow\; R_2C(OMgX)R' \;\overset{H_2O/H^+}{\longrightarrow}\; R_2C(OH)R' + Mg(OH)X

Applying it to acetone:

CH3−CO−CH3+CH3MgBr  →  (CH3)3C−O−MgBrCH_3-CO-CH_3 + CH_3MgBr \;\rightarrow\; (CH_3)_3C-O^-MgBr

and acid work-up gives

(CH3)3C−O−MgBr+H2O/H+  →  (CH3)3C−OH+MgBr(OH)(CH_3)_3C-O^-MgBr + H_2O/H^+ \;\rightarrow\; (CH_3)_3C-OH + MgBr(OH)

Therefore compound III is (CH3)3C−OH(CH_3)_3C-OH, namely tert-butyl alcohol (2-methyl-2-propanol).

Finally, III is tested with Lucas reagent (anhydrous ZnCl2ZnCl_2 + concentrated HClHCl). The Lucas test relies on the following:

- Tertiary alcohols give turbidity immediately.
- Secondary alcohols turn turbid in about 5 min.
- Primary alcohols remain clear for a long time.

Because turbidity appears at once, III must be a tertiary alcohol. Our deduction already shows III is tert-butyl alcohol, perfectly matching the observation.

Hence compound I must be the gem-dichloride CH3−C(Cl)(Cl)−CH3CH_3-C(Cl)(Cl)-CH_3, that is, 2,2-dichloropropane.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Nucleophilic substitution (SN1 and SN2). Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicNucleophilic substitution (SN1 and SN2)
TypeMultiple choice