RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2006TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2006 Chemistry question — Nucleophilic substitution (SN1 and SN2)

CH3Br+Nu−⟶CH3−Nu+Br−CH_3Br + Nu^- \longrightarrow CH_3 - Nu + Br^-ThedecreasingorderoftherateoftheabovereactionwithnucleophilesThe decreasing order of the rate of the above reaction with nucleophiles(Nu−)(Nu^-)AtoDisA to D is[Nu−=(A)PhO−,(B)AcO−,(C)HO−,(D)CH3O−][Nu^- = (A)PhO^-, (B) AcO^-, (C) HO^-, (D) CH_3O^-]$

SOLUTION

Methyl bromide undergoes a one-step SN2S_N2 substitution.
In an SN2S_N2 reaction the rate law is Rate=k [CH3Br] [Nu−]\text{Rate}=k\,[CH_3Br]\,[Nu^-], so for a fixed substrate and equal concentrations the relative rate depends only on the nucleophilicity of Nu−Nu^-.

When the attacking atom is the same (here it is oxygen in every nucleophile) the order of nucleophilicity parallels the order of basicity in the same solvent: the stronger the base, the faster it donates the lone pair to carbon, hence the faster the SN2S_N2 attack.

We therefore compare the basicity of the four oxygen anions.

Case 1 : CH3O−CH_3O^-
The negative charge is on oxygen bonded to an electron-donating +I+I methyl group. There is no resonance delocalisation, so the charge remains concentrated on oxygen, making CH3O−CH_3O^- the strongest base (and hence the best nucleophile) in the list.

Case 2 : HO−HO^-
There is no alkyl inductive donation, yet there is also no resonance stabilisation. HO−HO^- is therefore slightly less basic than CH3O−CH_3O^- but more basic than the anions that possess resonance delocalisation.

Case 3 : PhO−PhO^- (phenoxide)
Here the lone pair on oxygen can delocalise into the aromatic ring: PhO−↔PhOPhO^- \leftrightarrow PhO resonance structures. Resonance stabilisation lowers the charge density on oxygen, decreasing both basicity and nucleophilicity relative to alkoxide and hydroxide ions.

Case 4 : AcO−AcO^- (acetate)
In acetate the negative charge is shared equally by two oxygen atoms through resonance with the carbonyl group. This extensive delocalisation makes acetate the weakest base and correspondingly the poorest nucleophile among the four.

Putting the basicity (and hence nucleophilicity) orders together:

CH3O−  >  HO−  >  PhO−  >  AcO−CH_3O^- \; \gt \; HO^- \; \gt \; PhO^- \; \gt \; AcO^-

Therefore the decreasing order of the rates of substitution is

D  >  C  >  A  >  BD \; \gt \; C \; \gt \; A \; \gt \; B

Option A which is: D > C > A > B

Tagged Nucleophilic substitution (SN1 and SN2). Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicNucleophilic substitution (SN1 and SN2)
TypeMultiple choice