An 'Assertion' and a 'Reason' is given below. Choose the correct answer from the following options:
Assertion (A): Vinyl halides do not undergo nucleophilic substitution easily.
Reason (R): Even though the intermediate carbocation is stabilized by loosely held -electrons, the cleavage is difficult because of the strong bonding.
We have to check two separate things - first, whether the assertion about vinyl (alkenyl) halides is true, and second, whether the given reason is itself true and whether it really explains the assertion.
Vinyl halide means a molecule in which the halogen atom is directly attached to an -hybridised carbon atom of a carbon-carbon double bond, for example . Let us recall the two main nucleophilic substitution pathways:
1. mechanism 2. mechanism
For an process, the first step is:
That is, heterolytic cleavage of the C-X bond to give a carbocation. The stability of the intermediate carbocation determines whether this step is easy or difficult. A vinyl carbocation would look like
The positive charge resides on an carbon which possesses -character. Greater -character holds the electrons more tightly to the nucleus, so the carbon is already electron-deficient; adding a full positive charge makes the ion highly unstable. Therefore:
Because the required carbocation is extremely unstable, the path is practically blocked.
For an process, the nucleophile must perform a backside attack on the carbon that carries the leaving group, while the C-X bond breaks simultaneously. In vinyl halides, that carbon is part of a bond, i.e.
Geometrically, the bond occupies the region exactly where the nucleophile would need to approach, so backside overlap is impossible. Hence the path is also blocked.
Thus, vinyl halides do not undergo nucleophilic substitution easily. The assertion (A) is therefore true.
Now let us analyse the reason (R). It says: “Even though the intermediate carbocation is stabilized by loosely held -electrons, the cleavage is difficult because of the strong bonding.”
We have already seen that the vinyl carbocation is not stabilised; the -electrons are not “loosely held”. Instead, the high -character makes the positive charge on an carbon especially unstable. Hence the first part of (R) is wrong. The second part, about strong C-X bonding, is also inaccurate; the principal difficulty is not an exceptionally strong bond but rather the inability to form a stable carbocation or permit backside attack.
Therefore, the reason (R) is false, and it certainly does not explain the (true) assertion.
So, we have:
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.
Tagged Nucleophilic substitution (SN1 and SN2). Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.