RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 12 APR S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Nucleophilic substitution (SN1 and SN2)

An 'Assertion' and a 'Reason' is given below. Choose the correct answer from the following options:
Assertion (A): Vinyl halides do not undergo nucleophilic substitution easily.
Reason (R): Even though the intermediate carbocation is stabilized by loosely held π\pi-electrons, the cleavage is difficult because of the strong bonding.

SOLUTION

We have to check two separate things - first, whether the assertion about vinyl (alkenyl) halides is true, and second, whether the given reason is itself true and whether it really explains the assertion.

Vinyl halide means a molecule in which the halogen atom is directly attached to an sp2\mathrm{sp^2}-hybridised carbon atom of a carbon-carbon double bond, for example CH2=CH−ClCH_{2}=CH-Cl. Let us recall the two main nucleophilic substitution pathways:

1. SN1\mathrm{S_N1} mechanism 2. SN2\mathrm{S_N2} mechanism

For an SN1\mathrm{S_N1} process, the first step is:

R−X  ⟶  R++X−R-X\; \longrightarrow \; R^{+ + X^{-}}

That is, heterolytic cleavage of the C-X bond to give a carbocation. The stability of the intermediate carbocation determines whether this step is easy or difficult. A vinyl carbocation would look like

CH2=CH+CH_{2}=CH^{+}

The positive charge resides on an sp2\mathrm{sp^2} carbon which possesses 50%50\% ss-character. Greater ss-character holds the electrons more tightly to the nucleus, so the carbon is already electron-deficient; adding a full positive charge makes the ion highly unstable. Therefore:

Stability: vinyl  carbocation≪allyl  or  tert  carbocation\text{Stability: } \mathrm{vinyl\; carbocation} \ll \mathrm{allyl\; or\; tert\; carbocation}

Because the required carbocation is extremely unstable, the SN1\mathrm{S_N1} path is practically blocked.

For an SN2\mathrm{S_N2} process, the nucleophile must perform a backside attack on the carbon that carries the leaving group, while the C-X bond breaks simultaneously. In vinyl halides, that carbon is part of a π\pi bond, i.e.

C(sp2)C(sp^2)

Geometrically, the π\pi bond occupies the region exactly where the nucleophile would need to approach, so backside overlap is impossible. Hence the SN2\mathrm{S_N2} path is also blocked.

Thus, vinyl halides do not undergo nucleophilic substitution easily. The assertion (A) is therefore true.

Now let us analyse the reason (R). It says: “Even though the intermediate carbocation is stabilized by loosely held π\pi-electrons, the cleavage is difficult because of the strong bonding.”

We have already seen that the vinyl carbocation is not stabilised; the π\pi-electrons are not “loosely held”. Instead, the high ss-character makes the positive charge on an sp2\mathrm{sp^2} carbon especially unstable. Hence the first part of (R) is wrong. The second part, about strong C-X bonding, is also inaccurate; the principal difficulty is not an exceptionally strong σ\sigma bond but rather the inability to form a stable carbocation or permit backside attack.

Therefore, the reason (R) is false, and it certainly does not explain the (true) assertion.

So, we have:

Assertion (A): true,Reason (R): false\text{Assertion (A): true}, \qquad \text{Reason (R): false}

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Nucleophilic substitution (SN1 and SN2). Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicNucleophilic substitution (SN1 and SN2)
TypeMultiple choice