RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 12 APR S2+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Nucleophilic substitution (SN1 and SN2)

Which one of the following is likely to give a precipitate with AgNO3_3 solution?

SOLUTION

We first recall the standard qualitative test: when an alkyl (or benzyl/allyl) halide is treated with ethanolic silver nitrate, the halide ion X−X^- that departs from the molecule combines with the silver ion Ag+Ag^+ to form a curdy white precipitate of silver halide AgXAgX.

This observation is explained by the nucleophilic substitution mechanism. The rate of substitution for chlorides follows the order

tert-alkyl chloride>sec-alkyl chloride>prim-alkyl chloride≫vinyl or aryl chloride.\text{tert-alkyl chloride} > \text{sec-alkyl chloride} > \text{prim-alkyl chloride} \gg \text{vinyl or aryl chloride}.

Now we analyse each option one by one.

Option A : CH2=CH−ClCH_2 = CH{-}Cl (vinyl chloride)
The chlorine atom here is directly attached to an sp2sp^2 hybridised carbon of a C=C double bond. Such C−ClC{-}Cl bonds are very strong and do not undergo the usual SN1S_N1 or SN2S_N2 processes in ethanolic AgNO3AgNO_3. Hence no chloride ion is liberated, so no AgClAgCl precipitate forms.

Option B : (CH3)3CCl(CH_3)_3CCl (tert-butyl chloride)
This chloride is tertiary. In ethanolic medium the C−ClC{-}Cl bond ionises readily to give the stable tert-butyl carbocation  (CH3)3C+ \,(CH_3)_3C^+\, and the chloride ion Cl−Cl^-:

(CH3)3CCl  ⟶  (CH3)3C++Cl−(CH_3)_3CCl \;\longrightarrow\; (CH_3)_3C^+ + Cl^-

The released Cl−Cl^- immediately reacts with silver ion to give an insoluble precipitate:

Ag++Cl−  ⟶  AgCl↓Ag^+ + Cl^- \;\longrightarrow\; AgCl\downarrow

So a white precipitate appears quickly.

Option C : CCl4CCl_4 (carbon tetrachloride)
Although CCl4CCl_4 contains four chlorine atoms, the central carbon has no empty orbital for coordination and the molecule is quite resistant to ionisation in protic solvents. Therefore Cl−Cl^- is not produced and no precipitate is observed.

Option D : CHCl3CHCl_3 (chloroform)
Chloroform is also rather inert toward substitution under these conditions; the C−ClC{-}Cl bonds are not cleaved by ethanolic AgNO3AgNO_3, so again no Cl−Cl^- is released.

Among the four compounds, only the tertiary chloride (CH3)3CCl(CH_3)_3CCl readily furnishes chloride ions that can precipitate silver as AgClAgCl.

Hence, the correct answer is Option 2.

Tagged Nucleophilic substitution (SN1 and SN2). Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicNucleophilic substitution (SN1 and SN2)
TypeMultiple choice