When an organic halide reacts with aqueous or ethanolic silver nitrate (AgNO3), it undergoes an SN1 nucleophilic substitution mechanism. The silver ion (Ag+) assists in pulling away the halide ion (X−) to form a highly insoluble precipitate of silver halide (AgX).
Whether a compound will give a precipitate depends directly on the stability of the resulting carbocation formed after the removal of the halogen:
- If the resulting carbocation is stable (e.g., aromatic, allylic, benzylic, tertiary), the reaction occurs rapidly, producing a precipitate.
- If the resulting carbocation is highly unstable (e.g., vinyl, phenyl) or if the carbon-halogen bond has partial double-bond character due to resonance, the halogen will not leave, and no precipitate will form.
-
Option A (3-bromocycloprop-1-ene):
When it loses Br−, it forms the cyclopropenyl cation. This carbocation is completely planar, fully conjugated, and has 2 π-electrons, meaning it follows Huckel's rule (4n+2 where n=0). It is highly stable due to its aromatic character. Therefore, it reacts exceptionally fast with AgNO3 to yield a rapid precipitate of AgBr.
-
Option B (Benzyl bromide):
When it loses Br−, it forms the benzyl carbocation. This cation is highly stabilized by resonance with the benzene ring. As a result, it easily reacts with AgNO3 to form a precipitate of AgBr.
- Option D Furthermore, a phenyl or vinyl carbocation is highly unstable due to the positive charge being on an sp2 hybridized carbon.
Hence, Option D is correct.