RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 09 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Acidity and basicity of organic compounds

Acid strength given below the correct decreasing order will be:

SOLUTION

We want to compare the acidic strength of the four substituted acetic acids

XCH2COOH  (X=NO2,  F,  NC,  Cl).\text{XCH}_2\text{COOH}\;(X = NO_2,\;F,\;NC,\;Cl).

An acid is stronger when its conjugate base is more stable. When one of the hydrogens of the -COOH group is lost, the following equilibrium is set up

XCH2COOH  ⇌  XCH2COO−+H+\text{XCH}_2\text{COOH}\;\rightleftharpoons\;\text{XCH}_2\text{COO}^- + H^+

The acid-dissociation constant is written as

Ka=[XCH2COO−][H+][XCH2COOH],K_a=\dfrac{[\text{XCH}_2\text{COO}^-][H^+]}{[\text{XCH}_2\text{COOH}]},

and a larger KaK_a (or a smaller pKa=−log⁡KapK_a=-\log K_a) indicates a stronger acid. As soon as the proton is removed the negative charge resides on the carboxylate ion; any factor that withdraws electron density from the -COO- group will spread out (delocalise) that negative charge and lower the energy of the conjugate base, thereby raising KaK_a.

The factor that dominates here is the inductive effect (symbolised as -I). A group with a strong -I effect pulls σ-electrons toward itself through the σ-bond framework, reducing the electron density on the -COO- unit and stabilising it. The groups in question are compared below.

1. The -F group
Fluorine is the most electronegative element (χ = 4.0 on Pauling’s scale). Just one σ-bond away from the carboxylate, it exerts the strongest -I effect of all the substituents in the list. Consequently FCH2COO−\mathrm{FCH_2COO^-} is stabilised the most, and FCH2COOH\mathrm{FCH_2COOH} is expected to have the largest KaK_a (the smallest pKapK_a) and therefore be the strongest acid among the four.

2. The -NC (cyano) group
In the nitrile group the carbon is sp-hybridised and therefore very electronegative. This makes the -NC group a powerful electron withdrawer through the σ-framework. Its -I effect is slightly weaker than that of -F but still very large, so NCCH2COOH\mathrm{NCCH_2COOH} is expected to be the next strongest acid after FCH2COOH\mathrm{FCH_2COOH}.

3. The -NO2 group
-NO2 is well known for an intense -M (-R) effect on π-conjugated systems, but that resonance effect cannot operate through the saturated -CH2- bridge present here. Only its -I effect remains operative, and that -I effect, while strong, is a little weaker than that of the -NC group because two heavy atoms (N and O) lie one bond farther from the acidic centre, lessening the field-inductive pull. Hence NO2CH2COOH\mathrm{NO_2CH_2COOH} comes third.

4. The -Cl group
Chlorine is electronegative, but its -I effect is appreciably less than that of -F and just smaller than that of -NO2 and -NC. Moreover, because Cl has available 3d orbitals, a small +R effect can partly offset its -I pull, making its overall withdrawing ability the weakest of the four. Thus ClCH2COOH\mathrm{ClCH_2COOH} is the least acidic in the set.

As a result we have the decreasing order of acid strength

FCH2COOH  >  NCCH2COOH  >  NO2CH2COOH  >  ClCH2COOH.\mathrm{FCH_2COOH} \; > \; \mathrm{NCCH_2COOH} \; > \; \mathrm{NO_2CH_2COOH} \; > \; \mathrm{ClCH_2COOH}.

This sequence is exactly the one written in Option B.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Acidity and basicity of organic compounds. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicAcidity and basicity of organic compounds
TypeMultiple choice