Acid strength given below the correct decreasing order will be:
We want to compare the acidic strength of the four substituted acetic acids
An acid is stronger when its conjugate base is more stable. When one of the hydrogens of the -COOH group is lost, the following equilibrium is set up
The acid-dissociation constant is written as
and a larger (or a smaller ) indicates a stronger acid. As soon as the proton is removed the negative charge resides on the carboxylate ion; any factor that withdraws electron density from the -COO- group will spread out (delocalise) that negative charge and lower the energy of the conjugate base, thereby raising .
The factor that dominates here is the inductive effect (symbolised as -I). A group with a strong -I effect pulls σ-electrons toward itself through the σ-bond framework, reducing the electron density on the -COO- unit and stabilising it. The groups in question are compared below.
1. The -F group
Fluorine is the most electronegative element (χ = 4.0 on Pauling’s scale). Just one σ-bond away from the carboxylate, it exerts the strongest -I effect of all the substituents in the list. Consequently is stabilised the most, and is expected to have the largest (the smallest ) and therefore be the strongest acid among the four.
2. The -NC (cyano) group
In the nitrile group the carbon is sp-hybridised and therefore very electronegative. This makes the -NC group a powerful electron withdrawer through the σ-framework. Its -I effect is slightly weaker than that of -F but still very large, so is expected to be the next strongest acid after .
3. The -NO2 group
-NO2 is well known for an intense -M (-R) effect on π-conjugated systems, but that resonance effect cannot operate through the saturated -CH2- bridge present here. Only its -I effect remains operative, and that -I effect, while strong, is a little weaker than that of the -NC group because two heavy atoms (N and O) lie one bond farther from the acidic centre, lessening the field-inductive pull. Hence comes third.
4. The -Cl group
Chlorine is electronegative, but its -I effect is appreciably less than that of -F and just smaller than that of -NO2 and -NC. Moreover, because Cl has available 3d orbitals, a small +R effect can partly offset its -I pull, making its overall withdrawing ability the weakest of the four. Thus is the least acidic in the set.
As a result we have the decreasing order of acid strength
This sequence is exactly the one written in Option B.
Hence, the correct answer is Option B.
Tagged Acidity and basicity of organic compounds. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.