RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 09 JAN S1+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Acidity and basicity of organic compounds

Which amongst the following is the strongest acid?

SOLUTION

We have to compare the acid strengths of the four molecules CH(CN)3CH(CN)_3, CHI3CHI_3, CHBr3CHBr_3 and CHCl3CHCl_3. In every case the acidic hydrogen is attached to the same kind of carbon framework, namely a −CHX3-CHX_3 type group where the three substituents X are either CNCN, II, BrBr or ClCl. So the deciding factor is how strongly each group X withdraws electron density from the C−HC-H bond. A greater electron-withdrawing effect stabilises the conjugate base more, which in turn gives a stronger acid.

First, we recall the relationship between acid strength and the stability of its conjugate base. The acid-base equilibrium can be written as

HA⇌H++A−.\text{HA}\rightleftharpoons \text{H}^+ + \text{A}^-.

The equilibrium constant for this reaction is the acid-dissociation constant KaK_a, given by the formula

Ka=[H+][A−][HA].K_a=\dfrac{[\text{H}^+][\text{A}^-]}{[\text{HA}]}.

When the conjugate base A−\text{A}^- is stabilised by any effect (inductive, resonance, hyperconjugation, etc.), the numerator becomes effectively larger, the value of KaK_a increases and the acid is stronger (pKa=−log⁡KaK_a=-\log K_a becomes smaller).

Now we analyse the nature of the groups:

• The CNCN group exerts a very powerful −I (inductive) effect because the nitrogen is highly electronegative and is doubly bonded to carbon. Moreover, the CNCN group also has a −M (electron-withdrawing resonance) effect because the π\pi electrons can delocalise toward the nitrogen. Both effects strongly pull electron density away from the central carbon, greatly stabilising the conjugate base C(CN)3−C(CN)_3^-.

• The halogens II, BrBr and ClCl also show a −I effect; however, their strengths decrease in the order Cl>Br>ICl > Br > I because inductive withdrawal becomes weaker as the atom becomes larger and less electronegative.

• None of the halogens can offer an additional strong −M effect toward a saturated carbon the way the CNCN group does in this molecule, so their total withdrawing capacity is much less than that of CNCN.

So, to arrange the groups in order of total electron withdrawal we have

CN    ≫    Cl  >  Br  >  I.CN \;\; \gg \;\; Cl \; > \; Br \; > \; I.

Consequently, the conjugate base of CH(CN)3CH(CN)_3 is the most stabilised, giving the largest KaK_a and the smallest pKaK_a value among the four acids. In other words, CH(CN)3CH(CN)_3 is the strongest acid.

Therefore the order of acid strength is

CH(CN)3  (strongest)  >  CHCl3  >  CHBr3  >  CHI3  (weakest).CH(CN)_3 \; \text{(strongest)} \; > \; CHCl_3 \; > \; CHBr_3 \; > \; CHI_3 \; \text{(weakest)}.

Among the given options the molecule CH(CN)3CH(CN)_3 corresponds to Option A.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Acidity and basicity of organic compounds. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicAcidity and basicity of organic compounds
TypeMultiple choice