For a compound to be aromatic, it must fulfill four criteria:
- Cyclic: The structure must be a closed ring.
- Planar: All atoms in the ring must be sp2 hybridized so the p-orbitals can align.
- Fully Conjugated: There must be a continuous system of alternating double bonds, positive charges, negative charges, or lone pairs around the entire ring.
- Hückel's Electron Count: The conjugated loop must contain (4n+2)π electrons (where n=0,1,2,3..., giving allowed counts of 2,6,10,14...π electrons)
- A (Cyclopentadienyl Anion): Cyclic, planar, fully conjugated. It has 2 double bonds (4π e−) + 1 negative charge lone pair (2π e−) = 6π electrons (n=1). Aromatic.
- B (Tropylium Cation): Cyclic, planar, fully conjugated. It has 3 double bonds (6π e−) + 1 empty p-orbital from the positive charge = 6π electrons (n=1). Aromatic.
- C (Naphthalene): Cyclic, planar, fully conjugated bicyclic system. It has 5 double bonds = 10π electrons (n=2). Aromatic.
- D (Cycloheptatrienyl Anion): It contains 3 double bonds (6π e−) + 1 negative charge lone pair (2π e−) = 8π electrons. This follows the 4n rule (n=2), making it Anti-aromatic (non-aromatic in reality as it tubs to lose planarity). Not Aromatic.