CORRECT order of stability for the following is
We need to arrange three carbanions in decreasing order of stability.
Key Concept: Stability of carbanions depends on the hybridisation of the carbon bearing the negative charge. The greater the s-character of the orbital holding the lone pair, the closer the electrons are held to the nucleus, and the more stable the carbanion. The s-character of different hybridisations is:
- hybrid: 50% s-character
- hybrid: 33.3% s-character
- hybrid: 25% s-character
The carbanion (acetylide ion) features an -hybridised carbon bearing the negative charge. With 50% s-character, its lone pair is held closest to the nucleus, making it the most stable of the three.
In the case of (vinyl carbanion), the negatively charged carbon is hybridised. With 33.3% s-character, this carbanion has intermediate stability.
The carbanion (ethyl carbanion) is hybridised, possessing only 25% s-character, so its lone pair is held furthest from the nucleus. Additionally, the methyl group exerts a +I (electron-donating inductive) effect that increases electron density on the negatively charged carbon, further destabilising it. This is the least stable carbanion.
Therefore, the decreasing order of stability is .
The correct answer is Option 2: .
Tagged Reactive intermediates and rearrangements. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.