RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2022 · 27 JUN S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2022 Chemistry question — Aromaticity

Which of the following is most stable?

SOLUTION

Apply Huckel's rule for aromaticity.

A cyclic, planar, fully conjugated system is aromatic if it has (4n+2)(4n + 2) π\pi-electrons (where n=0,1,2,...n = 0, 1, 2, ...), and antiaromatic if it has 4n4n π\pi-electrons. Aromatic species are exceptionally stable, while antiaromatic species are very unstable.

Analyze each species.

Option A - Cyclopropenyl cation (C3H3+C_3H_3^+):

This has 3 carbon atoms in a ring with one positive charge. Number of π\pi-electrons = 2 (one double bond contributes 2 electrons; the cationic carbon has an empty p-orbital). With 4n+2=24n + 2 = 2 (n=0n = 0), this is aromatic and highly stable.

Option B - Cyclopropenyl anion (C3H3−C_3H_3^-):

This has 4 π\pi-electrons. With 4n=44n = 4 (n=1n = 1), this is antiaromatic and very unstable.

Option C - Cyclopentadienyl cation (C5H5+C_5H_5^+):

This has 4 π\pi-electrons. With 4n=44n = 4 (n=1n = 1), this is antiaromatic and unstable.

Option D - Cyclohexadienyl:

The cyclohexadienyl species is not fully conjugated (it has an sp3sp^3 carbon breaking the conjugation), so it is non-aromatic and less stable than an aromatic species.

Conclusion.

The cyclopropenyl cation (Option A) is the only aromatic species among the choices, making it the most stable.

The answer is Option A\boxed{\text{Option A}}.

Tagged Aromaticity. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicAromaticity
TypeMultiple choice