RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 27 JUL S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Chemistry question — Resonance and hyperconjugation

Given below are two statements:
Statement I : Hyperconjugation is a permanent effect.
Statement II : Hyperconjugation in ethyl cation (CH3−CH2+)\left(CH_3 - \overset{+}{CH_2}\right) involves the overlapping of Csp2−H1sC_{sp^2} - H_{1s} bond with empty 2p orbital of other carbon.
Choose the correct option:

SOLUTION

We begin by recalling that in any organic molecule there are two broad kinds of electronic effects - permanent effects, which are present in the molecule in the ground state itself, and temporary or induced effects, which appear only in the presence of an external reagent or field. The hyperconjugation effect belongs to the first category because the delocalisation of electrons arising from it is built into the normal electronic structure of the molecule; no attacking reagent is required to set it up. Therefore hyperconjugation is indeed a permanent effect.

Hence, Statement I, “Hyperconjugation is a permanent effect”, is correct.

Now let us examine the mechanistic picture of hyperconjugation in the ethyl cation CH3−CH2+.CH_3-CH_2^+. The second carbon (the positively charged one) is sp2sp^2-hybridised, so three of its sp2sp^2 orbitals form σ\sigma-bonds with two hydrogens and with the adjacent carbon, while the remaining unhybridised orbital is a vacant 2p2p orbital perpendicular to the molecular plane.

The electrons that can be donated through hyperconjugation are the σ\sigma electrons of the C-H bonds on the neighbouring β\beta-carbon, i.e. the CH3CH_3 group. Each such bond is built from

filled }C_{sp^3}\;( on the \text{on the }CH_3 carbon\text{ carbon}) \;+\;filled \text{filled }H_{1s

Expressed symbolically, one of these bonds can be written as

σ(Csp3−H1s).\sigma\bigl(C_{sp^3}-H_{1s}\bigr).

For hyperconjugation to operate, only the carbon lobe (the Csp3C_{sp^3} part) of this bond can align laterally with the empty 2p2p orbital on the positively charged carbon; the spherical 1s1s orbital on hydrogen has no directional preference and therefore cannot overlap sideways with that 2p2p orbital. In other words, the interaction is effectively between

filled Csp3 lobe\boxed{\text{filled } C_{sp^3} \text{ lobe}} and empty 2p orbital on C+.\boxed{\text{empty } 2p \text{ orbital on } C^+}.

The statement given in the question reads: “Hyperconjugation in ethyl cation involves the overlapping of Csp3−H1sC_{sp^3}-H_{1s} bond with empty 2p2p orbital of other carbon.” Because it speaks of the entire Csp3−H1sC_{sp^3}-H_{1s} bond overlapping with the vacant 2p2p orbital, it implicitly involves the hydrogen end as well, which is not capable of the required sideways overlap. Strictly, only the carbon end of the bond participates. Thus the wording of Statement II is inaccurate, and the statement is taken as false.

We therefore have: Statement I true, Statement II false.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Resonance and hyperconjugation. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicResonance and hyperconjugation
TypeMultiple choice